3 ms·
Yeah, it is a total mystery how adequately funding social welfare programs could somehow help the poor.
by jandrese 7y ago
Yeah, it is a total mystery how adequately funding social welfare programs could somehow help the poor.
- zajd 7y agoWelcome to HN, where taxation is "stealing"
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- onepointsixC 7y agoBenefits and welfare programs have been increasing dramatically as a percentage of GDP.
- droopyEyelids 7y agoHave people been getting poorer to qualify for welfare?
- jandrese 7y agoYes, the increasing wealth gap has been killing America. That's what this program is trying to address.
- kevingadd 7y agoIf the welfare programs are functioning correctly, any decrease in overall population wealth and/or income would naturally have to raise the welfare spend. The alternative would be for the newly poor to suffer and/or die in poverty, because only the existing poor were being assisted by the programs. Incidentally that does seem to be how much of the US safety net is designed to work and we've been actively trying to push more needy people out of the benefits programs, so that's something. This is a feedback loop. If "spend is going up" is somehow justification for cutting welfare programs or for not funding them, how does that fix anything? The ideal would be to have more than enough funding for all your programs, then work on ideal ways to utilize the extra funding. In the end if there's a surplus you can always cut taxes on the rich again, since US lawmakers are constantly trying to do it anyway.
- nightski 7y agoIt's not a mystery at all. But that does not address the wealth inequality. It just provides bare necessities to the poor (which is a great thing, it's just not what I was talking about).
- jandrese 7y agoTaking money from the top of the wealth gap and putting at the bottom seems like it should reduce the gap by simple mathematics.
- nightski 7y agoI just don't feel that is the case. Because money given to a poor person will likely be spent on essentials, not saved. The wealth tax will likely be less than what a wealthy person makes in capital gains/dividends each year so meanwhile their fortunes are growing. So while it definitely helps the poor, it's not going to tighten that gap. Something more fundamental needs to be done with corporations and how disproportional the rewards are to the owners/shareholders and the employees themselves. I have no idea what this would actually look like though.
- Pigo 7y agoI agree that many programs/departments need more funding, but the places with the most money seem to be doing the worst. It seems like more money is only part of the problem. I think if they showed better efficiency and results, the public would be much more inclined to contribute. There's a lot of cynicism from witnessing so much waste and mismanagement.
- mindcrime 7y agoYeah, it is a total mystery how adequately funding social welfare programs could somehow help the poor. If the government is going to steal my money, I'd like to think that it would go to something like that But in reality it goes to enriching the corrupt bureaucrats and politicians that make the rules and run the systems.