3 ms·
No one wanted people to die, it is not murder, at worst it is involuntary manslaughter. And maybe justice will come down to that conclusion and some people will
by GuB-42 7y ago
No one wanted people to die, it is not murder, at worst it is involuntary manslaughter. And maybe justice will come down to that conclusion and some people will end up in jail.
But is it the solution? Is it what should be done?
Because if people are going to jail, then who? There are probably hundreds of people who have some responsibility. There are the higher ups who encourage such behavior, those who are a bit too liberal with the rubber stamp, the liars, the ones who trust the liars even if it is their job not to, the ones who failed to report, the one who didn't listen for the reports, the engineers who designed the solution, and of course, the pilots, the flight instructors,... There are enough people for an entire prison city here.
This is not a case we can solve by pointing fingers. There is a systemic problem that needs to be solved. And just throwing a few people in prison will just result in Boeing hiring new scapegoats.
- sebastien_b 7y ago> No one wanted people to die, it is not murder, at worst it is involuntary manslaughter > Try again - more like criminal negligence at a minimum. > But is it the solution? Is it what should be done? Yes - there needs to be some serious consequences, not the usual typical 'Company shuts down, execs get huge severance while whistleblowers and investors get shafted' type thing. Also, some heads at the FAA need to roll. Utter failure of an agency that's supposed to protect the public. And I also hope the victims' families also sue for pain and suffering, because they're victims of this too.
- GuB-42 7y agoInvoluntary manslaughter implies criminal negligence or some other crime being committed. Otherwise it is just an accident. And I am not against the idea of serious consequences, the problem is about whose heads are going to roll? It is easy to blame the executives, they are high profile, they are rich, they are the kind of people we like to hate. But are they really at fault, execs are just employees serving the shareholders, and if you have Boeing stocks in your portfolio, then you are a shareholder, so maybe you should go to jail. And what will happen if the CEO goes to jail? The board of directors will name a new scapegoat CEO, there are many people who are ready to risk jail time in exchange for being the CEO at Boeing... Same thing about the FAA, except that's more about the politicians you elected than about the shares you bought... Putting a few high profile people in prison will certainly appease some vindictive minds, but I don't want vengeance, I just want safer airplanes. And as someone mentioned, they are already impressively safe despite all these shenanigans. As for the victims' families, of course they should be compensated. But I don't think putting random people in jail is the best way to do it. I am not saying that no one should go to jail. Some people most likely committed real jailable offenses, like corruption, and they should get punished. But making some heads roll for the sake of it isn't a good solution in my book.
- sebastien_b 7y ago> and if you have Boeing stocks in your portfolio, then you are a shareholder, so maybe you should go to jail. Personally, I'm not opposed to that type of thing happening - I always thought a company being "public" is an oxymoron, since they only serve the shareholders (just look how Facebook prefers to serve its shareholders/execs over democracy... but I digress). If you can't fund terrorist organizations without consequences, then I think there should be equal consequences when your demands for your share values compromise the safety of society. Also, might cause people to keep the companies 'in check' if their own butts were on the line too... But that'd be another whole discussion for another time... The whole point of consequences is to discourage future bad behaviour: "Wow, that guy's and his family's life is ruined now! Shit, I don't want the same thing to happen to me, I'd better be more careful than he was!". But if all anyone gets is a slap on the wrist, or find a scapegoat, then really what's the point of laws (especially when a nobody gets years in jail for a minor crime, but some high-profile execs can charm/buy their way out with little consequences). More and more of this reveals that there was very little "involuntary" things happening - they were quite deliberate in what they did, and knew what they were doing wasn't on the "up and up" and compromised safety (with even someone saying "I wouldn't fly on one of those!").
- xtracto 7y agoThey should apply eminent domain to shareholders and then auction the confiscated stock. That way the government (society) gets something, and shareholders in general would be more cautious of the crap they invest into.
- quickthrowman 7y agoIf you own any US equity large cap index funds, then you own Boeing stock.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> It is easy to blame the executives, they are high profile, they are rich, they are the kind of people we like to hate. But are they really at fault Yes. One of the things about being at such a high level is having responsibility. Responsibility means you are ultimately at fault for things that go wrong.