5 ms·
I don't understand this change. Why would this make the drivers any less of a employee or more of a contractor? If they were serious about the drivers being co
by rightbyte 7y ago
I don't understand this change. Why would this make the drivers any less of a employee or more of a contractor?
If they were serious about the drivers being contractors, the drivers should process the payment and give Uber commission for the lead.
- TomMarius 7y agoWhy should the driver process the payment? There are middlemen processing payments for hundreds of years.
- jfengel 7y agoI think the idea is "not Uber". If Uber is the only payment processor, then they look more like an employer and less like the middleman they want to claim to be. The money is coming from Uber to the driver rather than from the driver to Uber as their commission.
- TomMarius 7y agoThat is normal, e.g. if you travel through a federated regional bus/train transport system, you're paying through the platform and the company is processing your payment, sending money to individual transport operators. See flixbus as the most extreme example, but there are tons of these across Europe, many of them formed during post-communist privatization. Its similar with parcel delivery companies, these even are forced to have the PPL brand on their own cars!
- Litmus2336 7y agoIt seems to me that the option to refuse drives is the bigger change. But regarding pricing, Uber is no longer "mandating" the drivers accept a price, instead Uber drives agree to the rates Uber sets. Maybe that has some bearing? I'm no expert.
- sida 7y agoMaybe eventually uber needs to allow drivers to set prices for themselves, with a large enough market it should proxy surge pricing?
- Litmus2336 7y agoYeah, that'd theoretically work. But I wonder how it would go in practice with the limited information of each driver. Perhaps if they provided drivers with statistics (average offering price, bottom 10% offering price, ride volume over time, peak areas etc) then it would work. Interesting proposition.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThey could do it dutch auction style. Suppose there are five drivers and three rides. The drivers bid per-mile rates of $.75, $1, $1.25, $1.50 and $1.75. The rides go to the three lowest bidding drivers and they all get $1.25, i.e. the highest rate of the drivers who get rides. It gives everyone the incentive to bid their actual threshold past which they wouldn't want the ride, because if you bid too high you don't get any rides, but if you bid lower you may still get paid more than that unless bidding that low was actually necessary to get the ride. And at any given time all the riders pay the same rate as each other.
- nemothekid 7y ago>They could do it dutch auction style. Suppose there are five drivers and three rides. The drivers bid per-mile rates of $.75, $1, $1.25, $1.50 and $1.75. The rides go to the three lowest bidding drivers and they all get $1.25, i.e. the highest rate of the drivers who get rides. The problem with all these variables is that the more "preferences" you introduce into marketplace to matching, the longer your pickup time will be. The 2nd most frustrating change is going to be the increase in pickup times because drivers will now optimize for rides that are exclusively in city limits.
- 7y ago
- privateSFacct 7y agoThe problem is almost everyone in the US uses credit cards etc -> so having the driver handle the money is not easy - it almost always will need to go through someone else (usually a merchant gateway, merchant processor etc.). Taxi's do it by saying the credit card machine is "broken" to avoid the merchant / middleman charge - is that what you are proposing? If the drivers process all the amounts gross will they properly deduct the commissions paid to uber / lyft? I actually like the idea - just you are putting a fair bit on the drivers -> merchant accounts, chargeback handling and dispute resolution, etc. And you generally need good credit to manage all this.
- hurricanetc 7y agoIt changes the behavioral relationship between Uber and the drivers. If the company controls what the worker does and how the worker does it then the worker should likely be classified as an employee. By fixing the rates and giving drivers control over which rides to take Uber is strengthening their argument that drivers are contractors, not employees.