3 ms·
That wouldn't change the question being asked though. It can be murder with or without orders. With orders just means the culpability extends beyond HAL. Though
by ineedasername 7y ago
That wouldn't change the question being asked though. It can be murder with or without orders. With orders just means the culpability extends beyond HAL. Though I don't think it's proper to think of HAL as culpable unless you also attribute the ability to choose to HAL.
It's also so subjective of a question it is not really useful as a philosophical tool either. I describe one criteria for it being "murder", but reasonable people might easily come up with other, equally defensible stances. So interrogating this question doesn't reveal much more than societal divisions along semantic lines.
I think the more interesting questions are things like: what do we do about murderers? Punishment for its own sake? Deference? Rehabilitation? What is the primary goal of our legal system?
- JadeNB 7y ago> So interrogating this question doesn't reveal much more than societal divisions along semantic lines. Surely knowing that words mean different things to different people in the same society, and knowing what they mean, is quite valuable knowledge! > what do we do about murderers? … Deference? Is there any chance that 'Deference?' was a typo? I can't seem to make sense of it.
- ineedasername 7y agoOh, yes, revealing those societal divisions, the different meanings, can be an important activity. I just don't think, from a utilitarian "what's best for society" that it is the root question. The more fundamental question, I believe, is what does society do about such crimes? What are it's goals? The "is it murder" questions gains, I believe, much more relevance in that context. >Deference: Oops, that should be deterence
- edoo 7y agoIf HAL isn't a sentient being then it is a machine that has been programmed to murder under certain circumstances. If HAL is sentient then he did commit murder. Either way the people who instilled the orders would be culpable under the same rules that would apply if you arranged for someone to be murdered but did not do it yourself.
- ineedasername 7y agoAgreed! In part. Sentience may have... degrees. It does not instill absolute choice/free will in it's recipients. In fact there are rare neurological disorders that may cause someone to move their limbs involuntarily, but that doesn't negate their sentience. If one such pulled the trigger on a gun, is the sentient person a murderer? Let's complicate it a little more: sometimes a similar syndrome makes the person actually believe they are in control: their brain makes up reasons for why they moved a certain way. In that case, their sentient process actually might concur with the "murderer" label, but is would be absolutely wrong! So we come to HAL: it could be fully self aware but have as little choice as a light switch, or at least have such little choice in some circumstances. This is why I think sentience may be a necessary, but not sufficient condition for "murder". The ability to have chosen otherwise is, I believe, also a necessary condition.