4 ms·
No, it was "distorted" 2D, like cardboards put in perspective. Not 3D.
by anthk 7y ago
No, it was "distorted" 2D, like cardboards put in perspective. Not 3D.
- rasz 7y agoNo free look meant no perspective distortions in Doom.
- rusk 7y agoYou are still getting confused by polygons. It was a 3D space that you could move around in. The matter of how it was rendered is an implementation detail.
- anthk 7y agoYou coudn't look up and down, neither you could do with DN3D. I am not confused, the opposite. I grew up with that.
- rusk 7y agoI grew up with it too ... I disagree with your categorical boundaries. The distinctions you draw are purely technical.
- mtrower 7y agopurely technical? You can't go above or below anything; no two objects can exist at the same X/Y; height doesn't exist in any true fashion (the attribute is used purely for rendering --- there is no axis!). How is the existence of the third axis in a supposedly 3D environment purely technical? With only two axis, it is literally a 2D space, which gives some illusion of 3D as an implementation detail --- not the other way around.
- rusk 7y agoIt isn't "literally" a 2D space. It is "topologically" a 2D space in that you could represent it as a 2D space without loosing information. It doesn't provide 6 degrees of freedom but it is very much experienced as a 3D game environment. EDIT also, using the term "literally" to talk about 3Dness when it is all rendered onto a 2D screen, is fairly precarious. No matter how many degrees of freedom, or how rendered, it will never be "literally" 3D, in the literal sense of the term.
- rasz 7y agoYou can look up/down in Duke3D, its under home/end keys. It doesnt look pretty nor correct, but you can do it.
- likeclockwork 7y agoIt really wasn't. Doom's gameplay almost entirely took place in a 2D maze with one-way walls. It was rendered to look 3D, and as you said, that's an implementation detail.
- forthac 7y agoDoom was a 2D space that looked like a 3D space due to rendering tricks. You could never move along the Z-axis though because the engine doesn't represent, calculate, or store one. That's why you can't jump, and there are no overlapping areas of the maps.
- rusk 7y agoRegardless of the “technicalities”. My point was that this, and other 3D games were something that Amiga could not do well - whether 3D, or “simulated 3D”.