15 ms·
On one hand, this is a great effort and I'm sure will help commuters a ton. But on the other, why on earth does the bay area have 31+ different transit agencie
by paxys 7y ago
On one hand, this is a great effort and I'm sure will help commuters a ton.
But on the other, why on earth does the bay area have 31+ different transit agencies??
- romwell 7y agoTo ensure that we will never have a viable public transportation network that can make high-density mixed-use walkable urban environments possible.
- opportune 7y agoIf it actually worked well, people might use it, especially the undesirables. It’s also because the Bay Area is stupidly split up into dozens and dozens of small-medium sized municipalities spread over multiple counties. So every little group acts in their own locally optimal, shortsighted interests. Most of the people affected worst by the lack of public transportation and housing can’t vote in the areas that can actually fix the problem. I’ve been thinking the past couple of years you should be able to vote in local elections in the area you work in, even if you don’t live there.
- jcims 7y ago>I’ve been thinking the past couple of years you should be able to vote in local elections in the area you work in, even if you don’t live there. Makes sense to me, especially if you are paying local income taxes in that area. I seem to recall from high school that 'taxation without representation' caused a big kerfluffle a couple hundred years ago.
- opportune 7y agoI don’t think there are local income taxes (at least visible to the employee) but they are IMO a part of the community, pay taxes indirectly (property taxes where they work, sales taxes, etc.) and should have a say because of that.
- jcims 7y agoAhh, maybe in CA. In Ohio you have to pay income taxes where you work and where you live. If they are different places then there are usually some kind of weird commuter credits that never actually offset the difference.
- BorgHunter 7y ago> I’ve been thinking the past couple of years you should be able to vote in local elections in the area you work in, even if you don’t live there. In many areas this would effectively lead to the suburbs being able to dictate urban policy to the inner city, where suburban commuter interests like parking override the interests of the actual residents. The 1998 amalgamation of Toronto is a good example of this happening, and I think a lot of Old Toronto voters are quite unhappy with this, given how it led to mayors like Rob Ford who would never have been elected with the old boundaries. Other areas try to solve this by creating an uber transit authority which theoretically directs and coordinates the smaller agencies for the greater regional good. A good example of this is the Regional Transportation Authority in Chicago. It often doesn't work out the way it's intended (in Chicago, the CTA [city proper transit] and Metra [commuter rail] still have very poor coordination, although Pace [suburban buses] and CTA do have somewhat good coordination). A third approach is to (try to) make the whole region's transit the responsibility of one single agency. Picking Atlanta as an example here (MARTA), it tends to lead to affluent suburbs (Cobb and Gwinnett Counties) trying to stay out of the system because of concerns like "transit brings crime" and "it's too expensive and no one will use it" and other assorted nonsense. So that approach has its problems too. In short, this is a very thorny problem and there honestly aren't a lot of places in North America that do it very well, although some are worse than others (the SF Bay Area may seem like a mess, and it is, but it's inarguably better than the dozens of barely-funded, not-at-all-sufficient systems that exist in most large and medium cities in the U.S.). I think the right solution is probably specific to each region and it still won't solve every problem, at least not without a level of funding that transit simply does not get on this continent.
- derefr 7y ago> In many areas this would effectively lead to the suburbs being able to dictate urban policy to the inner city Then perhaps "urban policy" is an unnatural category, combining conflicting interests. Why not just have two municipal governments—one elected by those whose business interests lie within the city, which would be in charge of the city's business policy (e.g. corporate taxe and grants, arterial infrastructure, commercial zoning); and a separate one, elected by the city's urban residents, which would be in charge of the city's civic policy (e.g. estate taxes and VATs, non-arterial infrastructure, residential zoning, etc.)? These are essentially orthogonal problems that don't really "run into" each-other much; you could have two separate sets of people working on solving them without those groups needing to communicate all that much. Municipal government is already somewhat factored this way, insofar as e.g. school boards and park boards are separately elected rather than being appointments of the municipal executive; and some of those elections are defined by different political boundaries (e.g. catchment areas for schools) than the election of the municipal executive is. Why not just go one step further?
- dmead 7y agoliterally everyone who commutes into a city for work wants to also vote there. good luck with that.
- fossuser 7y agoAren't there enough of us to leverage power by voting as a block? I know Palo Alto Forward was trying to do this a while back - it'd be nice if we could block vote in people that could massively upzone housing (or make whatever change is necessary to increase housing supply). Myself and a lot of my friends live in these towns with roommates - I'd think if there was a clear group to vote for and clear policy to push to increase housing we'd have a lot of votes. It's hard to even find what the existing law around building housing is, is it online anywhere?
- zpallin 7y agoYou should look into supporting https://www.transformca.org https://www.transformca.org which works with Bay Area governments already to solve transportation policy. They have already contributed immensely to transportation accessibility in the region, and have been at the forefront of the BRT fight, but it's an uphill battle and they need more support.
- forwhomst 7y agoTo fix this support https://www.seamlessbayarea.org/ https://www.seamlessbayarea.org/
- zpallin 7y agoOr, perhaps https://www.transformca.org https://www.transformca.org which already has a track record of working with local governments and successfully implementing transit policy.
- Domenic_S 7y agoThis is exactly the problem. It's so inefficient. 31+ executives (and top-paid people), 31+ budgets, 31+ locally-optimized goals and preferences. It's completely nuts.
- brodouevencode 7y agoGood point. And I would like to also point out that this is another example of the Valley fixing its own problems instead of problems we all share. All we ever hear outside of the Valley is how the Valley is going to save us. And yes, there is a lot of troll in that comment :P.
- mullen 7y agoBecause there is no Emperor of California who can come through, with a single stroke and merge agencies together. Once those agencies were created, they were never going to be merged with other agency.
- et-al 7y agoGoogle Maps and the Transit App already ingest GTFS feeds for trip routing and predicting arrivals. A regional feed would make things easier for developers, not so much commuters, who are already relying on aforementioned products. For anyone interested in playing with GTFS feeds in their area, I recommend checking out TransitFeeds' list: https://transitfeeds.com/feeds https://transitfeeds.com/feeds
- mc32 7y agoAgreed. They need to merge and coördinate agencies. Someone like abag could become the MTA or the ny-nj port authority.
- unlinked_dll 7y ago- Nine counties - 7,000m^2 - 7.75 million people - 101 municipal governments Shocking that we only have 31+ transit agencies. The place is dense!
- deathanatos 7y agoIt's a lot larger than 7,000m^2 :)
- unlinked_dll 7y agoha, the metric system strikes me again!
- dx034 7y agoThe number of goverments is the only reason though. London also only has one transit agency with a similar population (and maybe size).
- shadow-banned 7y agoThe Bay Area (once a generation of boomers passes) will HAVE to become more like NYC - with "cities" (using that term loosely for places like Cupertino, Mountain View etc as these are really sterile suburbs with trip malls) becoming more like "boroughs" with an overarching authority. We're talking a 30 year timeline, though.
- desert_boi 7y agoYou should read "Cities without Suburbs" if you want to know the politics around consolidation and how hard it is in most of the states. A lot of it boils down into tiny municipalities being able to avoid a cripple larger metros that the littler metros hem in.
- jedberg 7y agoIt should be noted that San Francisco is smaller than San Jose by quite a bit, and all the cities in the south are suburbs of San Jose. If that magic combination ever happened, it would be San Jose as the main city. And somehow I don't think San Francisco would be happy being a borough of San Jose.