3 ms·
The premise isn’t that housing is treated as an investment. The premise is that housing is personal property. (Just like bread, etc., and many other things nece
by rayiner 7y ago
The premise isn’t that housing is treated as an investment. The premise is that housing is personal property. (Just like bread, etc., and many other things necessary for life.)
It’s cities that are turning housing into an investment through laws turning it into a scarce resource. (Not just laws against building, but laws against short term rentals, boarding houses, tenements, etc.). It’s unsurprising that homelessness is actually decreasing in the US as a whole, whole increasing in wealthy cities: https://www.economist.com/united-states/2019/10/19/homelessness-is-declining-in-america https://www.economist.com/united-states/2019/10/19/homelessn....
But this is mostly a San Francisco and New York problem. In 2015, about 10,000 people in San Francisco experienced homelessness at any time in the past year. That’s 112 per 10,000 people. (This is a different, and better, measure than the “homeless on a given night” instantaneous measure.) That same figure in Iowa is about 9 per 10,000. The national average is around 20-25 per 10,000.
- pmoriarty 7y agoSan Francisco also has survivable winter temperatures, many shelters and other infrastructure to help the homeless, etc. I remember being in Penn Station in NYC on many nights when homeless people slept in the waiting rooms. Police would routinely come by and kick them out. When this happened during the winters in sub-zero temperatures this meant a very real risk of death for the homeless who were forced to sleep outside. I wonder if it's the same in other parts of the nation, and if the reason there are only 25 homeless per 10,000 nationwide is that the rest have died of exposure during their winters (or from other types of neglect).
- asdff 7y agoMore homeless die of hypothermia on the streets of Los Angeles than they do in NYC. You can die of exposure when it's 50*, especially if you are wet from rain or sweat.
- pcwalton 7y ago> (Just like bread, etc., and many other things necessary for life.) Yes, this is a very good point. You don't see people vilifying farmers for making profits on food, even though some people go hungry. But for some reason people hate developers for making a profit on housing. (In my opinion, all of the NIMBY arguments, very much including the vacancy one in the article, are just attempts to mask the real reason for opposing housing—a preference for the suburban lifestyle.) > But this is mostly a San Francisco and New York problem. It's not just a San Francisco and New York problem. Add Seattle, Los Angeles, San Diego, Portland, Austin, Miami, and Boston/Cambridge to that list, just to name a few. That's not even counting non-US cities like Vancouver, London, Paris, etc. I agree that housing shortages are unevenly distributed, of course.