7 ms·
> “I'm an attorney by trade,” he said. “So this is something I know something about.” The artist would clearly win his case in court, and sounds like he has th
by crazygringo 7y ago
> “I'm an attorney by trade,” he said. “So this is something I know something about.”
The artist would clearly win his case in court, and sounds like he has the resources to do it, so I'm not worried. And after all, the "geometric" style subway map has prior art as the London Tube map starting in 1931 [1].
But I can't imagine what is going on at the MTA that they felt compelled to try to take this down in the first place. What on earth do they think they're trying to accomplish with it? Is there some kind of legal liability they think they're protecting themselves against? They're a governmental agency for crying out loud.
It truly boggles the mind.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tube_map https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tube_map
- wefarrell 7y agoThey’re not a governmental agency and their governance is much closer to a private corporation.
- JackFr 7y agoWell not quite. They are a public benefit corporation, and their governance is through a 21-member board. Board members are nominated by the Governor, with four recommended by New York City's mayor and one each by the county executives of Nassau, Suffolk, Westchester, Dutchess, Orange, Rockland, and Putnam counties (the members representing the latter four cast one collective vote). There are also non voting members representing unions and commuter groups. For most purposes, they are a government agency, except for, and most especially, borrowing money. They have no taxing authority, and debt obligations of the corporation are NOT debt obligations of the state, and thus do not count against statutory limits on state borrowing, nor do they affect the bond rating of the states general obligation borrowing.
- wefarrell 7y ago"For most purposes" Care to elaborate? That's a pretty vague argument.
- JackFr 7y agoMost purposes: They are governed by a board appointed by the governor. While not employees of the state, by law their employees are regulated under the Civil Service Law. Other purpose: Their debt is not an obligation of NYS.
- JackFr 7y agoIANAL but I think prior art is a reason to exclude patents, not copyright. All IP is not the same.
- icebraining 7y agoYes and no. The idea is that the MTA is claiming that it must be derived from their map, since its style is so similar; by showing there were similar maps made before, the argument becomes less credible.
- jordigh 7y agoThe point is that "prior art" is a term of art, unapplicable to copyright.
- jordigh 7y agoIn fact, all IP is quite different, to the point that even calling it "IP" leads to a lot of confusion thinking that it's at all similar.
- wizzwizz4 7y agoObligatory Stallman essay: “Did You Say “Intellectual Property”? It's a Seductive Mirage” https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/not-ipr.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/not-ipr.html
- throwaway_tech 7y agoI agree the artist wins the case, but on fair use not prior art. The following quotes in an email essentially kill any possible MTA case: >“Yes, there are minor differences between your map and the MTA map,” Freundlich wrote in his email. “But given your access to the MTA map on the MTA website, and the substantial similarities of your map to the MTA map, the only rational conclusion is that your map is based on the MTA Vignelli map.” MTA acknowledges the artist map is based on the MTA map and acknowledges differences no matter how minor.
- nck4222 7y agoAlso pointed out in the article, the "copy cat" map was made 2 years before the official MTA map that it's so similar to.
- niklasrde 7y agoNo, it was made in 1972. In 2011 it was just brought back, but it had been published before.
- logfromblammo 7y agoThe artist's map is based on the facts of MTA subway service and station locations, and common principles of data visualization. If the artist gleaned facts from the official MTA map, and re-represented them on his own map, that does not make his a derivative work, even if the facts came solely from the map. The facts also could have come from riding every line and noting the station names and locations. It's like copying a phone book. You can take numbers from AT&T's customer directory and put them in your own phone book, because that's all facts. There's no creative representation there. If the phone book represented the numbers in hand-drawn calligraphy, that visual representation would be protected, but not the factual content; you could still copy the names and numbers and re-render them in your own typeface. Fair use doesn't even come into it. Naked facts are non-copyrightable. They have no protections whatsoever. Facts are public domain.
- Lammy 7y ago
- technotarek 7y agoIn terms of MTA motivation, aren't they just trying to protect it as an asset to limit its usage and thereby increase its potential value so that they can best monetize it? In this day and age where some spend their days trying to dissemble and neuter government traditional means of raising revenue, I don't necessarily find the approach problematic (putting aside the particulars of this specific case).
- icebraining 7y agoBut the MTA does not seem to be monetizing their maps.
- technotarek 7y agoYou sure? "That article also claimed the MTA received $500,000 a year in licensing revenue, a whopping .003 percent of the agency’s 2013 revenue." Perhaps this isn't from the map, but either way, the logic of my suggestion applies equally to protecting the asset for future monetization as much as current monetization.
- finestkludge 7y agoAlso, with the general state of the MTA, it is infuriating that this is where they're directing resources.
- Someone1234 7y agoThey should use the money they're spending on this to license the artist's map and use it. It is a substantial improvement over their one. But instead they're trying to suppress a superior design using faulty copyright arguments.
- whlr 7y agoI dunno. It looks like an improvement on the Vignelli map, but I think the less pretty one the MTA uses today is more functional.
- couchand 7y agoLet's consider a few use cases and see which one is more useful: - Given two stations, is there a line between them, and what is it? Edge to Berman's, as it distinguishes service on the same corridor. - Given a station on a line, what are the next few stops? Berman's wins, since the MTA map requires reading the lines that stop at each station. - Weekday service. A push, shown by both maps. - Weeknight service. Berman's wins, as the MTA map doesn't show it. - Weekend service. Berman's wins, as the MTA map doesn't show it. New Yorkers have gotten used to getting the information we need from the MTA map, but let's not confuse familiarity with functionality.
- fennecfoxen 7y agoThe purpose of a map in the abstract is not merely to answer questions about how to connect two points within a specific transportation system, the subway. Other possibilities include: connecting two locations above ground, understanding the connections and relationship among various places above ground, and even simply enumerating some of those places. New York City's map shows a variety of out-of-system features which the designer's map doesn't bother with: railroads, avenues, major cross streets, major bus corridors (the original identifies airport link stops but not routes), local commuter rail corridors (LIRR, Metro North), regional rail corridors (Amtrak), ferries, road bridges, tunnels, the Roosevelt Island Aerial Tram, and many more parks. The MTA map this more effectively answers more-general questions about New York. It can tell you to walk through the park between the Natural History Museum and the Metropolitan Museum of Art. This does come at the cost of interfering with several of the more-specific questions you identified.
- nerdponx 7y agoBut I can't imagine what is going on at the MTA that they felt compelled to try to take this down in the first place. What on earth do they think they're trying to accomplish with it? Is there some kind of legal liability they think they're protecting themselves against? They're a governmental agency for crying out loud. My guess is it's one person in a legal department operating somewhat independently trying to make a big splash with some higher-ups. That's the only way it would make sense to me.
- JackFr 7y agoWhy shouldn't they? For the sake of argument, assume that their claim is valid (and it's not obvious to me it isn't). Why shouldn't a government agency be a responsible steward of all of its assets including its intellectual property? I hav a LOT of problems with the MTA, but this isn't one of them.
- dvtrn 7y agoI'm not sure I understand your statements, at once you've said it's obvious to you their claim isn't valid but then you say this isn't a problem for you? Merely looking for clarification, does playing Lawyer's advocate really work if you've already acknowledged the claim has no merit?
- JackFr 7y agoI said it's NOT obvious that it isn't valid. I'm saying it's reasonable to argue as if the claim were valid to make my other point, that they should be a responsible steward of their IP.
- dvtrn 7y agoMy apologies, I completely misread the comment in parenthesis and did not realize having done so, but glad I sought out the clarification. Thank you.
- romwell 7y ago
- xenocyon 7y ago> The artist would clearly win his case in court ... so I'm not worried. Laws have chilling effects though, so the fact that one defendant who happens to be well-resourced and legally savvy is able to fight this battle does not mean that everything is OK.
- Rapzid 7y agoI chalk it up to "The MTA employs a bunch of lawyers. Those lawyers need to show they are doing something." Pretty standard stuff.
- romwell 7y agoPerhaps the MTA should retain fewer lawyers then.
- jrockway 7y agoThis was something that was brought up in some sort of efficiency review that was recently done. More concerning than New York City Transit having too many lawyers is that all the sub-agencies duplicate these departments... so there is a team sitting around at the LIRR, MNR, etc. doing similar things for their sub-agency. It is not an efficient organization.
- CodeWriter23 7y ago> They're a governmental agency for crying out loud. Actually, the MTA is a Public Interest Corporation. There is a difference. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metropolitan_Transportation_Authority https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metropolitan_Transportation_...
- MisterTea 7y ago> But I can't imagine what is going on at the MTA that they felt compelled to try to take this down in the first place. What on earth do they think they're trying to accomplish with it? Officially licensed MTA merchandise bearing iconic NYC transportation graphics for tourists and transplants.
- derefr 7y ago> Is there some kind of legal liability they think they're protecting themselves against? Loss of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trade_dress https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trade_dress protection?
- anigbrowl 7y agoMost likely they think that if they don't sue, they'll lose their intellectual property interest. This would be true if they were suing over a trademark, where undefendended infringement creates a defense of abandonment.