4 ms·
If the choice is between blocking a well-made, free app and not blocking it then it's clear that they'd benefit more from not blocking it. Everyone would win.
by onion2k 7y ago
If the choice is between blocking a well-made, free app and not blocking it then it's clear that they'd benefit more from not blocking it. Everyone would win.
But that's not the choice.
It's really a choice between blocking a well-made, free app and hundreds of other apps that vary in quality, price, etc, or not blocking any of them, or trying to assess each app on an individual basis. Not blocking anything means their own app will be lost in a swarm of low-quality rip-offs. Assessing each app is hard, and opens the door to complaints (and maybe law suits) about why one app was allowed and another wasn't. It's far simpler, easier, and dare I say fairer to block everything.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoThis line of thinking is what pushes me more and more against patents and copyright. A lot of creativity and innovation gets killed because somebody has a diffuse fear of something bad happening so let’s just kill everything.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThis line of thinking is pretty sad IMO, even if pragmatic at times. The best way to get rid of low-quality copycat apps isn't to ban all apps, it's to go after the reason those low-quality copycats exist in the first place. That is, advertising. There's no point in making a garbage app unless you can trick some people into installing it, and monetize them before they notice and delete the app. Advertising (in general, meaning both showing ads and harvesting data for the advertising industry) is what enables these apps. Curtail that, and there won't be a need to make any choice here.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoThe free market should separate good from bad apps like it does with everything else.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThe free market doesn't work well with fly-by-night operations, or with sticker price being 0 and money being made indirectly. Advertising as main revenue source destroys the mechanism of competition and its consumer-facing benefits.
- onion2k 7y agoApp stores don't work like a free market.
- abnry 7y agoYou could argue this saves money in the long run. If a 3rd party resource is not clearly marked as third party, you can get angry people wasting customer service resources over a poorly made product.