5 ms·
I think what society is really missing is this sense of belonging. We're raised to think that wealth correlates with happiness but it clearly doesn't. History
by muzani 7y ago
I think what society is really missing is this sense of belonging. We're raised to think that wealth correlates with happiness but it clearly doesn't.
History has always formed these loops of prosperity, then spirituality. I mean it's nice not to starve, but I think people would be happier being part of a tight knit tribe who support one another, even more than having air-conditioning and dating apps.
- blaser-waffle 7y ago> We're raised to think that wealth correlates with happiness but it clearly doesn't. Studies show it does, to a degree. Once you hit something like $70-80k the satisfaction levels off. It's one of those hygiene things -- not having it will make you (or others) miserable, but having it doesn't mean you're good or happy.
- muzani 7y agoFor the individual, yes. For a society, I think the culture of making as much as possible has left everyone slightly worse off, instead of slightly better off as we were promised.
- harimau777 7y agoDo you think that trying to get everyone to the 70k level (or the equivalent in their region) has made society worse off?
- muzani 7y agoIf society was focused on getting everyone to 70k, everyone would be happier. But instead, modern society encourages people to make as much as possible, create as many jobs as possible, and pay as close as possible to 15k.
- pseudalopex 7y agoSome measurements of stress and sadness level off. Satisfaction keeps going up logarithmically.
- zozbot234 7y ago> I think what society is really missing is this sense of belonging. Social capital is what gives people this sense of belonging - of being in a "tight knit tribe". I think that conservatives understand this a lot better than progressives, who tend to see everything about society in terms of either material conditions (wealth vs. poverty), or zero-sum power relations where one side 'wins' and the other side 'loses'. It's not clear that these matter all that much. Plenty of people throughout history had very little in the way of material resources, and were required to answer to people, institutional frameworks etc. exerting some sort of power on them - and yet, they still found lots of ways to smile and be happy at their life. We should understand how they managed to do that.
- Ar-Curunir 7y ago??? If anything, conservatives and liberals, due to their devotion for capitalism, are united in fracturing people and communities. That's just the natural end goal of an economic philosophy that views everything via the lens of corporate profit.
- zozbot234 7y agoCapitalism is an economic system centered around market relations, which has little to do with how "people and communities" organize themselves socially. The two issues just have very little to do with each other.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoCould you elaborate on your thinking in regards to loops? I honestly can't think of anything like that. It's not like the Romans were focused on prosperity and then the dark ages were spiritual - as near as I can tell, for the movers and shakers it's always been about power, and for the underclasses it's survival, just with whatever veneer you want to put on it. In fact it's only recent that the commoner could even aspire to wealth, regardless of whether that actually correlates to ability to achieve it.
- muzani 7y agoBuddha is textbook - rich fellow who realizes that it hasn't made life better. Islam went through many cycles of this. Corrupt powerful pagan Quraish. Spiritual Muhammad and Rashidun caliphate. Corrupt Umayyad Caliphate. Spiritual Abbasid Caliphate. The Ottomans went through this as well. We're historically at a low point with regards to Islamic society. Third world faces this - many of them have abundant natural resources, compared to say, Europe. But the wealth brings corruption, not prosperity. I think the Rashidun Caliphate has a lot of good examples - caliphs turning down state gifts, distributing most of the wealth, selling off luxuries like silk, jewelry, and carpets for infrastructure, making sure that their families didn't profit from state funds. Anything where an individual can benefit unfairly from the effort of an organisation is a form of corruption, as it involves abuse of power entrusted. This includes CEOs overpaying themselves, or government leaders with excessively high compensation. They're making use of their position to skim resources for personal benefit, and sadly, it's a culture now that this is what people should aspire to. Things usually improve when people can draw a line where they have enough, and allocate excess resources to the rest of the organization. This is usually (not necessarily) triggered by spirituality because there's nobody else to keep the watchmen in check. Once leaders do this, those down the command chain also do the same. There were plenty of situations where commoners were well off - in Egypt, Rome, China, Caliphates, and so on. I believe we actually have lower social mobility today than in some eras of the past, but it's far from terrible. I could well be wrong, and encourage those with more understanding of history to correct and give counter examples.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoRelated to this, I recall two issues that could inform his Hong Kong life expectancy point: 1. A recent study that found very high life expectancy "blue zones" were highly correlated with poor record keeping and pensions - the strong implication was that it was mostly fraud. Don't think Hong Kong was one of the areas studied, but I think skepticism is warranted. 2. A common thread I've seen in many longevity studies is that social connectedness is one of the strongest predictors of a long lifespan, and contrarily, "lonely people die young." I'd expect that a very close-knit urban area with relatively low migration (e.g. as opposed to NY or SF where there is so much moving in and moving out) would exhibit this social connectedness.
- rusk 7y agoI think there's a large undocumented migrant population too, who make up a lot of the working classes and this could skew that stats as well. EDIT it's a lovely place too, Hong Kong (picturesque, pleasant climate, easy to get around). I'd say that would have a lot to do with it as well, once you can pay the rent ...
- maroonblazer 7y agoWhat kind of research project does that translate to?
- muzani 7y agoWe're missing a socioeconomic model that isn't communism or capitalism. Socialism seems like an economic patch, but it's not a satisfactory solution. Socialism is sort of like how free range chickens seems nice but only when compared to how horrid the caged ones have it. A lot of brainpower in the last century went into technological progress, but we have enough computing power, internet, cloud, data to work on this thing.
- rusk 7y ago> but it clearly doesn't. Misery is a very strong inverse correlate however. I'd be given to thinking that a lot of economic activity is driven by the need to escape [EDIT and stay out of] poverty on one end, and a cohort of super-competitive success-addicts on the other. Most other people are quite content in the middle, and want to stay there. It is the threat of penury we should be looking more at than the lure of riches.