4 ms·
I would add new ways of searching in Internet. If I searched for food recipes in the 2000s I would find independent blogs with some real local/family taste. Now
by wslh 7y ago
I would add new ways of searching in Internet. If I searched for food recipes in the 2000s I would find independent blogs with some real local/family taste. Now I have a hundreds of results from click bait sites with the same commoditized recipes and the ugly blog with a good recipe deep in the long tail. We can say that we need improvements in the long tail when the tail deserves to move up (or to the left in a xy chart).
Internet search is a driver for the world economy, a tiny improvement would improve the life of entrepreneurs and their ecosystem beyond elite circles.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gombosg 7y agoIMHO this is because of SEO. Whatever algorithms search companies make, those who exploit them (called SEO, whatever the hat color is) will have an advantage over those who don't.
- lkschubert8 7y agoUnless the algorithm could actually detect "quality" (instead of poor analogs for it). Then if SEO couldn't really exploit it, SEO would just be making "quality" content.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rchaud 7y agoSEO is only half the issue. Even a great SEO won't be able to get your site to rank if it only has 10 pages and new content is rarely added (think of a small company's marketing website). Search engines think volume of content and frequency of updates are positive signals, so in the past decade we have seen a deluge of "content marketing", with corporate blogs and media sites chock-full of absolute garbage clickbait and listicles, written by freelance copywriters for pennies per word. All to obtain a higher domain ranking, or domain authority. While users are looking for the needle in the haystack, websites are just making the haystack bigger to capture users who were looking in a different haystack.
- zozbot234 7y agoThe problem with this is that black-hat SEO's have learned to mimic "independent blogs" and their linking/referencing networks (blogrolls, etc.) to the point that search engines are basically forced to discount all of these results. We need trusted, curated guides to the "independent" Internet, like the ODP/DMOZ of old. For both humans and search engines alike.
- pcmaffey 7y agoIve got a half baked project for a blog search engine that won’t index any pages with ads...
- yifanl 7y agoHow do you define "ad"? Keep in mind that as soon as you do define it, people are going to look for a workaround.
- bostik 7y ago> How do you define "ad"? Attempt to sell. Whether that's for an agenda, a product, a way of life, service, access, or anything else with a direct (or indirect) transaction of value - it's a dead giveaway.
- yifanl 7y agoIs a recipe for my grandma's minestrone soup (which requires you to buy a specific brand of chicken stock) selling you something? Is a blogpost highlighting a particularly efficient way to write a tight loop selling you something? Is a plain white webpage selling you the benefits of that particular shade of white?
- _fs 7y agoAre you saying that you don’t enjoy the 4 page life retelling story intermixed with countless ads and the same staged photo from 5 different angles and 4 different focal points when you just want to see the recipe? Luckily, there is an extension to parse all that out. https://github.com/sean-public/RecipeFilter https://github.com/sean-public/RecipeFilter
- cpach 7y agoFunny that you mentioned the issue of googling for recipes. We discussed it in another thread just the other week: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21938261 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21938261 I agree that it’s a tricky and quite big problem.
- rchaud 7y agoIt's a problem that's solved by buying a dedicated recipe cookbook. I don't mean to be blunt but at this point, we all know the game these recipe blogs are playing. There is simply no way to monetize users of such basic text content without plastering those pages with autoplaying videos, email signup modals and a million HTTP requests to ad and analytics servers.
- throwno 7y agoNot exactly what you're describing, but try this: https://millionshort.com/ https://millionshort.com/
- rchaud 7y agomillionshort.com is a search engine that lets you exclude high-ranking, SEO-gamed domains from your search. You can remove the Top 10, 100, or 1000 domains from your results. It might not exclude the recipe blogs you're talking about (I dislike those as well), but is a step towards finding more long-tail search results.