3 ms·
Maybe geolocked sites shouldnt be posted on HN unless OP provides screenshoot or tldr of contet there
by rtyturtu 7y ago
Maybe geolocked sites shouldnt be posted on HN unless OP provides screenshoot or tldr of contet there
- salzig 7y agoI support this thought.
- iso947 7y agoIt’s not obvious if a site is geolocked. I know Bbc is blocked in China from experience, but I wouldn’t expect that others would know. Hacker news is available in China (at least last time I was there).
- Crosseye_Jack 7y agoThe difference between BBC blocked in China and Chicago Tribune blocked in the EU I’m my opinion is CT actively block the EU because they don’t want to deal with the GDPR but China blocking the BBC is a decision outside of the BBC’s control.
- iso947 7y agoBut how do I, as a resident of Brazil, know that CT is blocked in Europe?
- Crosseye_Jack 7y agoI was just comparing the two sites. I'm not saying Geo-Blocked sites should be banned on HN, As I said in another comment, I think the same rule that applies to paywalls should be applied to to sites that geoblock themselves (Not being geoblocked by a goverment which the BBC is in China). If their are workaround for a paywalled site then its allowed on HN. So if their are workaround for the geoblocking (outline, google cache, archive.today, etc)then I think they should be allowed. As for how you will know if a sit is blocked, the same way people find out about soft paywalls, the comments will tell you. Its not like a crime to post paywalled sites to HN.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Crosseye_Jack 7y agoIt’s like paywalled sites. If it’s a soft paywall with known bypasses they are generally allowed on HN. If their are known bypasses for sites that geoblock (outline, google cache, archive.today) then I think the same rule should apply.