6 ms·
>These two numbers might seem very different, but both are central to Asimov’s legacy Yeah, I really don't think so. The legacy of people with important contri
by coldtea 7y ago
>These two numbers might seem very different, but both are central to Asimov’s legacy
Yeah, I really don't think so. The legacy of people with important contributions (technical, cultural, political, etc) is their work, not what they did in their private life, unless they were also moonlighting as the Boston strangler or something.
In 2500 nobody would care whether he did this or that. But they would probably still read some of his work.
- sytelus 7y agoIt's not about reading his work, it's about being an aspirational figure that generations want to follow and emulate. I didn't know any of these about Asimov and he has written some of the stories that I believe is the finest. But would I say to my kids "look at this great guy, be like him!"?
- coldtea 7y ago>It's not about reading his work, it's about being an aspirational figure that generations want to follow and emulate. People can still "follow and emulate" the achievements he did, not whatever bad side. Like people still try to follow all kinds of public figures, despite their known bad sides, from Hemingway to Jobs. Else we would only follow saints. () not to mention, if the tide turns, even the bad side could be "cool" again. There are even people into things like satanism or self-destruction, or womanizing, or machoism after all, and they too have their idols.
- doliveira 7y agoHonestly I never could relate to this focus I see nowadays on role models and aspirational figures. I think you should at most get inspired by specific actions scoped to the relevant areas of their lives. Just tell your kids to be themselves. They don't need to emulate anyone.
- scandox 7y agoWell his personal issues with women definitely are apparent in his work. His female characters are often shrieking ninnies. Also I don't think anyone but an academic will be reading his work in a few hundred years. As much as I enjoy his ideas and his easy style he is actually mediocre.
- lawlessone 7y agoI hadn't noticed this before about his female characters.. and now i can't unotice it that you have mentioned it
- scandox 7y agoYou know it was quite common in those days for Pulp Sci Fi...but for example the character of Jezebel Baley in The Caves of Steel is so bad that it almost suggests actual hatred on the part of the author.... certainly contempt.
- gerikson 7y agoIf you choose to name your character Jezebel[1] you might have an ulterior motive... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jezebel#Cultural_symbol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jezebel#Cultural_symbol EDIT on the other hand, from the same page - > In his two-volume Guide to the Bible (1967 and 1969), Isaac Asimov describes Jezebel's last act: dressing in all her finery, make-up, and jewelry, as deliberately symbolic, indicating her dignity, royal status, and determination to go out of this life as a queen.
- ethanbond 7y agoThe characters in the book discuss the symbolism of her name. She goes by "Jessie" because she does not want to identify with Jezebel. Apparently some commenters here would have us believe that if there's a highly emotional woman, it's because the author hates women. Jezebel's/Jessie's husband and main character of Caves of Steel, Elijah, is himself kind of an anxious headstrong type who's wrong more often than he's right. Of course, this indicates with high certainty that Asimov also hates men. Edit: Also worth noting that Bliss/Gaia in Foundation is pretty much the most powerful character in the Foundation universe. Mayor Branno, woman mayor of the First Foundation, is also revered as an incredibly capable and bold leader by all accounts. Edit 2: And not to mention the young girl taken from Solaria, who is the only character to potentially rival Bliss. What a laughable claim that all the women in Asimov’s stories are weak or hysterical.
- Ar-Curunir 7y agoThe fuck? Sexual harassment is as much part of his legacy as his novels. It drives out people from your field if your leaders are lauded despite being terrible to others.
- coldtea 7y agoNo field has any shortage of leaders / people being "terrible to others" in this and other ways. People could take issue in how their leaders, and people they interact with are today. If, on the other hand, they take issue for past leaders being lauded for their "within-the-field achievements" despite their personal behavior (as if that has any bearing on the field), especially after 50+ odd years, then those people "driven out" weren't that driven to be in the field in the first place. Would anybody go off of physics because Einstein was sexist (and worse), and still (rightly so) lauded as the greatest physicist (perhaps after Newton)? Not sure when people forgot how to compartmentalise...
- watwut 7y ago> Would anybody go off of physics because Einstein was sexist (and worse), and still (rightly so) lauded as the greatest physicist (perhaps after Newton)? It affected his wife I think (she was actually good in math). I think Einstein behavior was more personal through. He was never in "public figure groping women while everybody knows about it and culture adjusts to accept and enable" category. And like, it is ok to talk about Einstein flaws too, why do we need to pretend that past figures were better then they actually were? > they take issue for past leaders being lauded for their "within-the-field achievements" despite their personal behavior Asimov was not successful despite his personal behavior. His personal behavior happened because of his success and escalated with success. It is the way people in power accepted the acts that they would not accept from somebody else. The lauding of great people is often based on lie - either by omission or direct. The exactly same impulse of "must not criticize him" is what make people enable his behavior and would make people enable next successful person. > then those people "driven out" weren't that driven to be in the field in the first place. I think this is nonsense. Of course people take rational decisions about which field they can be reasonably successful in and where they can will be treated badly. It is like with companies - most capable employees tend to leave faster when faced with toxic management.
- watwut 7y agoAfaik, everything the article writes about is his public life. None of it is privite dispute with wife or who he dated.
- coldtea 7y agoPrivate as in not in his public output/work, not "private" as in inside his house or with his spouse.
- afro88 7y agoThe legacy of their work is tainted by their person. Two things are independently true: 1) Asimov was a prolific writer who authored many works that were fundamental in shaping science fiction into what we know it as today 2) Asimov sexually assaulted women on a regular basis But the way people see the first point will be through the lens of the second.
- coldtea 7y ago>But the way people see the first point will be through the lens of the second. Only certain people, who think themselves as saints and that others should be too, and judge creators by their failings. Most people care just for the work -- the fact they actually matters to them in 2020 and that they get to read --, and they could not give less ducks who some creator was and what they did in their personal lives.
- DagAgren 7y agoNot "most people". But people without a functioning moral compass, sure. That is not something to be proud of, though.
- ses1984 7y agoThere is only a limited amount of time available to me. I can only consume so much media. If I have a choice between two books, one written by someone with a tainted legacy and one written by someone without a tainted legacy, I'm going to pick the book with a nice author. Of course you can't really apply ceteris parabus to books, but normally you have to decide what you're going to read on limited information, two very different books might seem close enough given you know little about either. When you choose what to read you reduce all the context and comparison to a decision. "author was a creep" definitely makes me less likely to want to read his work, especially if they are still alive and could personally profit.
- thrower123 7y agoWhich one is good though? Saints rarely make anything that is above mediocre quality. It's sad, but it is empirically true. Jesus, if we had omniscience into the personal lives of every person, and were to chose to disregard their works if they did things that are objectionable to the taboos of the day, we'd be naked, looking over our shoulders fearfully for leopards.
- chris_wot 7y agoThey will care. His contributions will still be remembered, but history doesn’t forget transgressions. Nor should it.
- coldtea 7y ago>His contributions will still be remembered, but history doesn’t forget transgressions We don't care for the transgressions (including much more serious, down to murder, slave ownership, and other things) for 99% of historical figures...
- mercurysmessage 7y agoSome of us actually do care, and we should actually care about this. Don't put people up on pedestals that don't deserve it.
- zentiggr 7y agoThen there will be very very few pedestals, and small ones when there are at all. I have no trouble believing that everyone has done or said or caused something that could be called out. I am not making excuses or forgiving anyone. I'm just trying to point out that using today's "acceptable" to judge the past will devalue everything that's ever been accomplished. E.g., no doubt Salk had ideas about male/female roles in society that would be considered poorly today. That should be acknowledged as part of his time. Does that affect the success of the polio vaccine?
- mercurysmessage 7y ago"Then there will be very very few pedestals" And? Why does that matter to you? "I'm just trying to point out that using today's "acceptable" to judge the past will devalue everything that's ever been accomplished" I disagree, even in the time of the Founding Fathers it was common knowledge that slavery was bad, they just didn't care. Is that not wrong? And in this case, clearly Asimov knew that what he was doing was wrong. We can call out what these figures did as being wrong, while also acknowledging the work that they have done.
- jean_tta 7y agoIf I understand your comment, you are saying that what people do in their private life does not matter unless it is important enough (e.g. being the Boston strangler): this is tautological (what is important in the legacy of someone if the important things they did, their work and/or their private life if their private life is important). You are just saying that hundreds of such "incidents" is simply not important enough to be remembered. But murder would be according to you. Where do you draw the line?
- Gibbon1 7y agoI'll drop right in here to say the in their private life argument doesn't fly here. Because the complaints aren't about his private relationships, they're about public and professional behavior. Frankly the callousness of people like Asimov bothers me. You're left with two possibilities. Either they simply don't care that they are making the other person uncomfortable, angry or scared. Or worse that they're getting off on that.