3 ms·
I believe this is a misconception, and I'm not sure where it comes from. Blacks on LCD screens really are quite black -- and if you dim your screen to ambient
by crazygringo 7y ago
I believe this is a misconception, and I'm not sure where it comes from.
Blacks on LCD screens really are quite black -- and if you dim your screen to ambient brightness, they obviously become even blacker.
This is why I said it takes a few minutes to get used to -- it "seems" dim or low-contrast, but only because you're comparing it with the ultra-mega-high contrast your monitor has when turned up to high brightness. When compared to paper (where "black" ink often isn't that dark anyways, particularly with matte finish like most books), the contrast is certainly just as good.
- zozbot234 7y agoYou could drive down the backlight intensity to try and keep the contrast the same, but then the whole screen would start flickering like crazy due to PWM - and that's assuming that the hardware even supports being driven down to that level! It can also be hard to recover if you accidentally drive the backlight down too much or even turn it off altogether!
- crazygringo 7y agoI'm not sure what you mean -- both my MacBook and iPad let me reduce the backlight intensity to very little, and there's zero "flickering like crazy" at all. What devices have this problem? I've personally never encountered it on any LCD screens I've ever owned.
- kalleboo 7y ago> both my MacBook and iPad let me reduce the backlight intensity to very little I don't agree - I have a long-standing complaint that Apple doesn't let you reduce the brightness on their devices enough! I would definitely want to lower the brightness on my MacBook Pro more at night if I could. On my Mac I've even used third-party software that overlays the screen with a semitransparent black square to darken it, but that reduces contrast. On my iPhone I use the accessibility filter to darken the screen. I assume they've limited the minimum brightness due to PWM flicker.
- crazygringo 7y agoSo... yes, I've experimented with that on the Mac too (I think it was "Shady" or something?), so you certainly can. But that doesn't reduce contrast beyond what's inherent in reducing brightness -- the blacks when the backlight is at minimum power in a dark room are black. You seriously don't get blacker than that in any practical sense that is relevant to the human eye, certainly not on the high-quality displays MacBooks have. I don't know what you are trying to say with the word "contrast", but a utility like Shady does exactly what you're asking for -- reduces brightness below the minimum -- with zero negative optical side effects. It seems that whatever you're expecting it to do (dimmer but better contrast) is literally a physical impossibility.
- BlueTemplar 7y agoProbably a fluorescent-backlight LCD rather than a LED-backlight LCD ? EDIT : Huh, looks like both are susceptible to the issue, but diode-crystal has it actually worse than fluorescent-crystal ? https://www.infobyte.hr/blog/134/ccfl-vs-led-screen-backlight-is-led-really-better/ https://www.infobyte.hr/blog/134/ccfl-vs-led-screen-backligh...
- projektfu 7y agoLED brightness is usually modulated with PWM which involves turning them on for shorter periods of time. Eventually it appears to flicker.
- mortenjorck 7y agoThe GP is probably thinking of low-end TN panels, which really do have poor contrast, combined with significant variance in off-axis brightness and color reproduction, further exacerbating the problem. These were extremely common until only recently, with even Apple's pre-Retina MacBook Airs using them. A modern IPS panel, however, can offer much higher contrast than most e-paper displays, and should offer a comparable experience to e-paper if set to an appropriate ambient brightness and color temperature. This last part is key, because otherwise, you end up with a harsh, bluish cast in residential lighting scenarios. Most TVs and monitors can have their color temperature set manually, but the only OEM I'm aware of that is doing this automatically right now is Apple with its "True Tone" displays.
- hbosch 7y agoThere is a complete difference between a light emitting screen and a light absorbing screen. Even backlit Kindles are much nicer to read on than iPads of the exact same "brightness".