3 ms·
> This simply isn’t true. Silo staff will know if the US is suffering a massive ground invasion or ICBM bombardment, and will have a very clear idea of whether
by vkou 7y ago
> This simply isn’t true. Silo staff will know if the US is suffering a massive ground invasion or ICBM bombardment, and will have a very clear idea of whether launching nukes is reasonable.
If they are being ordered to carry out a first strike, they have no idea of whether or not that first strike is reasonable, or not. And it's not their job to second-guess.
> There is no scenario where the US will be tactically dependant on using a nuke to destroy a site, so your “if I don’t launch the nuke Americans will die” scenario is perhaps the least plausible part of your comment.
Tactical nuclear strikes aren't launched out of silos. If a silo gets an order to fire, it's not a tactical launch, it's a strategic 'the world is ending (Possibly because we decided to end it)' launch order. Most silo operators will carry that order out.
- AmericanChopper 7y ago> If they are being ordered to carry out a first strike, they have no idea of whether or not that first strike is reasonable, or not. A first strike of nuclear ICBMs is never going to be reasonably justified. Even if we ignore the fact that there is absolutely no basis for speculation that the POTUS would ever order such a strike, there is no basis to speculate that silo personnel will comply with an order that is clearly unlawful, a crime against humanity, a war crime, and risks the complete destruction of human civilization. Out of all speculative scenarios, this has to be the least plausible.
- vkou 7y agoThis is just wishful thinking. The facts are: 1. The United States has a first-strike policy, and has invested billions of dollars in making sure that it can actually carry it out. 2. It adheres to it on the basis that its command staff believe that there is some moral calculus under which a first-strike is not genocidal or unlawful. 3. A first strike is not even abhorrent to average Americans. Around half of American citizens support a nuclear first strike if it results in saving American lives. 4. There are morons that believe that a nuclear war is winnable. Some of those morons become politicians, while others become generals. As far as I'm aware, there is no anti-moron filter on either occupation, that keeps those people away from positions of power. You may observe that your moral hangups, and the international-court legality of a first strike has zero bearing on any of those four points. And those four points are what will drive people to act the way they will act. Let's recap: * A first strike is not illegal under American law. It is a heavily studied topic, on which hundreds of thinkers, paid by the Pentagon, have produced thousands of documents that argue about when it can be used, and how it can be best used. * A first strike is not ever going to be an out-of-the-blue-POTUS-woke-up-on-the-wrong-side-of-the-bed event. * It is going to be a decision that is made in the middle of a geopolitical crisis, after weeks, or months of threats, escalations, and counter-escalations, and the occasional shot, or shell, or conventional missile being fired. It is going to be a dramatic, but possible decision to make in that context. * Because it is permitted by law, and because it has been argued for so exhaustively, and because the military has deliberately implemented procedures for carrying it out, the people who will be arguing for it will not have the same moral revulsion that you and I hold against it. * Those people also happen to be convinced that there is such a thing as a winnable nuclear war. In this context - when a silo operator receives the order to fire, when they know that there's a military and political crisis going on, and people are dying, many of them are going to follow their orders. After, they will have plenty of time to ponder whether or not the International Crimes Court at the Hague is going to hold their decision against them. What we need is a modern "Day After" moment. It's been a generation and a half since that film. The new crop of armchair generals, politicians, and office holders, who grew up with no memory of war, need to be reminded of its horrors. If a media mogul who owns a national television station is reading, I emplore you to consider broadcasting that film on the next Fourth of July. Or, alternatively, after the next State of the Union address.
- AmericanChopper 7y ago> The United States has a first-strike policy, and has invested billions of dollars in making sure that it can actually carry it out. This is simply an outright fabrication. The US has a qualified No First Use policy, stating: > The United States will not use or threaten to use nuclear weapons against non-nuclear weapons states that are party to the NPT and in compliance with their nuclear non-proliferation obligations And > It is in the U.S. interest and that of all other nations that the nearly 65-year record of nuclear non-use be extended forever The policy specifying when nukes can be used lists: > significant non-nuclear strategic attacks > attacks on U.S. or allied nuclear forces, their command and control, or warning and attack assessment capabilities > in extreme circumstances to defend the vital interests of the United States, its allies and partners And regarding low yield nukes, that their purpose is to: > help ensure that potential adversaries perceive no possible advantage in limited nuclear escalation, making nuclear employment less likely https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4365530-2018-Nuclear-Posture-Review-Final-Report.html https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/4365530-2018-Nuclear... Your claim that “The United States has a first-strike policy” is so demonstrably made-up, that you should honestly be ashamed of yourself.
- jeswin 7y ago> Your claim that “The United States has a first-strike policy” is so demonstrably made-up, that you should honestly be ashamed of yourself. We should be more civil in contentious matters. The US and almost everyone (except China) have a qualified First Use Policy.
- gsnedders 7y ago> If they are being ordered to carry out a first strike, they have no idea of whether or not that first strike is reasonable, or not. And it's not their job to second-guess. Though it is their job to refuse to carry out the order if it is unlawful (under both US and international law), which a first-strike may well be (as any first-strike is quite probably an act of genocide). The obligation not to follow unlawful orders (like killing civilians) while also their entire job being firing a weapon meant to kill indiscriminately is… interesting. I won't disagree that anyone who is likely to consider questions of indiscriminate murder of civilians and other such things prohibited under law will likely be structurally excluded from being put in such a position by the military.
- lunaticlabs 7y agoThis matches with what I heard from a former silo officer. I did a tour of the Atlas Missile Museum outside Tuscon, AZ, which holds the distinction of being one of the only fully intact but non-functional missile silos that you can visit. The tour itself, when I went, was given by an officer who used to be stationed at the silo when it was operational (being an Atlas, they were only in service for a short time), so I believe that was in the 50s. I asked him more or less this exact question, and here's how he explained it (and I remember it). They were on 2 week shifts, with 2 weeks on, 2 weeks off. When you enter the silo, you were ID'd over a camera on the outside, and only then would the officers being relieved unlock the door and let you in. If you got launch codes, you verified them with your partner (every place near the launch area was a 2 man zone), and then you both had to turn a key within a few seconds of each other. The keys were not within reach of each other. Once the launch sequence began, you basically powered everything down. Once the keys are turned, it is autonomous, and you basically aren't needed anymore. You didn't know if it was real, or if it was a test, and you were not aware of whether the missile would even launch or not. When it did launch, and it ended up being a test, you were notified more or less by the arrival of the next shift. As he put it, if the next shift didn't arrive, then you'd wait it out until you ran out of food, and then figure out what you would do. But he discussed the overall setup, and said he'd turned that key many times, as had all the other officers. The silo staff aren't going to know if its a legitimate launch or not, they are not trained to ask that question, and they are specifically conditioned in a way that leads me to believe that if an order came down, no matter how crazy, it would be executed by anyone who was outside of the decision hierarchy.