3 ms·
I agree entirely that the strategic benefits of using a low yield nuclear weapon are dubious at best. Then again, that didn't stop them being manufactured, hasn
by notahacker 7y ago
I agree entirely that the strategic benefits of using a low yield nuclear weapon are dubious at best. Then again, that didn't stop them being manufactured, hasn't stopped other military actions dubious strategic benefit have been carried out or advocated by senior military personnel, and you yourself cited the example where the
only thing stopping a low yield nuclear attack during a moment of incredible geopolitical tension was that their particular rules of engagement allowed an officer to veto what the other two wanted.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoLooking at the Soviet instance more closely, they were sent with a nuclear weapon into conditions where they had no communication with the outside world, and almost no information about the conditions above them or the status of the conflict, with orders to use a nuke if certain conditions were met, knowing they were being relied upon to do so. Putting aside the fact that having this kind of scenario repeated today is already very unlikely, this seems like a scenario where the use of a nuke would the least implausible. As the conditions were met, and the nuke was not used (in a scenario where it would be much more plausible than any one I’ve heard put forward today), this casts significant doubt on any speculation that military personnel would be prepared to launch nukes if ordered to do so.