3 ms·
Author is overthinking and taking teaching too seriously (religiously). Buddhism has concept called the Two truths doctrine. Ultimate truth and provisional tru
by nabla9 7y ago
Author is overthinking and taking teaching too seriously (religiously).
Buddhism has concept called the Two truths doctrine. Ultimate truth and provisional truth. There are also parables in the sutras where Buddha describes his teaching as not being the ultimate truth itself.
In the parable of dad saving his children from burning house , dad uses fancy toys to draw the attention of kids so that they walk out of the burning building. Essentially bullshitting them.
There is also comparison of his teaching to a raft to cross the river. Teaching has utility value to get people across, it's not useful to carry it after the river is crossed.
Another thing in Buddhist thinking is consideration to how different people understand things and what they need psychologically. There are people who just want to hear from authority figure what to do and they believe it and just do it (maybe majority of people). You must teach them in a that way.
As a modern interpretation of this, my teacher told me that the point of his public talks is to tell people something that makes them to attempt meditation seriously until it 'clicks'. The practice itself sorts out those who can do it and can't. Most people will never be into it anyway. The motivation and reasoning that makes people to start does not really matter at all.
The name Buddha gave to his religion was not Buddhism. It was Dhamma-vinaya, 'doctrine and discipline'. In my experience after being involved with mediation circles for 20 years, gym-rats used to hard training and daily discipline have much better start with meditation than people like me who are overthinking and analyzing, and who try to make sense of everything said. Instructions are there to help with training, you don't go to mediation retreat to learn philosophy.
- zozbot234 7y ago> In my experience after being involved with mediation circles for 20 years, gym-rats used to hard training and daily discipline have much better start with meditation than people like me who are overthinking and analyzing, and who try to make sense of everything said. Perhaps true, but "overthinking and analyzing" is not the only failure mode or even the most common one. Many people view Buddhism as little more than a fashionable, 'exotic' practice, with many elements of a social club. These folks are even less likely to undertake vipassana (insight) meditation successfully! At least if you're an analyzing type, reading something like Ingram's 'Mastering the Core Teachings of the Buddha' will tell you plenty of useful things about how vipassana is supposed to work, and what progress you have made along the way at any given time. The vast majority of people who approach Buddhism or even "meditation" of some sorts aren't even aware in the least that these are issues one could care about!
- proverbialbunny 7y agoIn Theravada Buddhism becoming an Arhat is the gaining of wisdom / loss of ignorance into dependent arising of suffering. You could make the argument that is philosophy, philosophy into the ultimate. If you meditate without learning and growing and analyzing the causality of different kinds of suffering (that is, psychological stress) eventually overcoming them, you'll never become enlightened. If anything, the analyzing type is the ideal type for enlightenment. Maybe not for meditation, but definitely for figuring things out. A trick is to not get in the way of what you're observing. If it feels bad there is a natural tendency to try to change it, but if you're changing it, then you can't observe it in a clear and scientific way hampering learning and growth. If you want to try to figure out solutions to suffering, it can be done after meditating, but meditation itself is not getting involved, beyond setting breakpoints (called noting) to accelerate awareness if the same problem arises. If you find yourself getting involved in stressful ruminations, it is helpful to remember that stress/suffering is impermanent and will disappear on its own without any involvement, so you can relax even while stressed. This has the side effect of increasing awareness because involvement decreases awareness. However, being avoidant outside of meditation often makes the problem worse, so it is important to not have aversion. There needs to be a middle ground here, as with everything else.
- zozbot234 7y agoVipassana meditation is specifically not based on 'analysis' of a conventional sort. It's raw unparalleled insight into your phenomenology (in the Husserl sense) - the generally-unnoticed details of your subjective experience. This is why it's considered so effective at going through the stages of 'enlightenment'.
- proverbialbunny 7y agoIt is effective at increasing awareness, which is necessary for enlightenment, but even Stream Entry is based on wisdom, which comes from learning how, eg, taking thinks personally works in relation to suffering. Some do gain stages of enlightenment while meditating, but I suspect the majority gain those stages at the end of their meditation session, when they switch from meditating to analysis putting together what they just saw. Also, Arhat is usually achieved while reading suttas, and Once Returner often is achieved when socializing. Stream Entry is the only common enlightenment obtained while meditating.
- sargossamaru 7y ago>gym-rats used to hard training and daily discipline have much better start with meditation than people like me who are overthinking and analyzing this right here is a good summation of why buddhism is just a cult of advanced physiology, those 'too much in their own head' and the truly mentally ill never do well in it. Buddhists like Alan Wallace insist this is a condition of fortunate conditions of karmic rebirth, in which those who have both social access to the Buddha's teaching and the neural complexity and health to integrate it successfully are in a 'Higher' rebirth caste than others.
- nabla9 7y agoI disagree. There are certainly some people who can't do it, but most people can. The most common reason why people can't do it is exactly the same reason why people start physical exercise, or start eating healthier or any self improvement and then fail: problem in self regulation and the ability to maintain routine. Big part of monastic type training and retreats is just fixing this very thing. The group and the routine comes from outside, you can do it.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoDon’t forget that Buddhism is about compassion. If someone is struggling the compassionate thing is to give them advice they understand.