6 ms·
The HN title is ambiguous. The point of the Twitter thread is that it doesn't exceed them combined. But then he writes: > (By the way, the article in question
by crazygringo 7y ago
The HN title is ambiguous. The point of the Twitter thread is that it doesn't exceed them combined. But then he writes:
> (By the way, the article in question put AirPods revenue at $12 billion in 2019. The actual number will end up being more like half that - closer to $7.5 billion.)
Which means it still exceeds each of them separately.
Just to put that in context for everyone here. If his analysis is correct, AirPods are still bigger than Spotify, which is fascinating to think about.
- ecmascript 7y agoI don't get whats weird about that? You need some kind of device in order to listen to Spotify and today there is a lot of services competing with Spotify. Spotify also have a huge number of free accounts that rely on ads which probably means less profits for Spotify. Everyone still needs to actually spend money to get the device but you don't really need to spend money to listen to music. Also, while Airpods is a "one off" purchase, a lot of people don't like having subscriptions (like me for example). I have spent hundreds of dollars the last years on headphones (not Airpods tho) but I hesitate for a long time before starting a subscription service. Not because I cannot afford to, I just do not like subscription services. Spotify, Youtube Music etc provide a free service. With adblocker, music.youtube.com is totally free without any ads so I have a really hard time to justify the cost of another paid service like Spotify. Edit: if you downvote this, please comment on why? What is incorrect about my statements?
- crazygringo 7y agoJust that it used to be the opposite for most people. When I was in my teens, I spent waaay more money on CD's than I ever did on my Discman and headphones. The fact that it's now the norm to spend more money on your audio hardware than on what you listen to is just an interesting reversal.
- moretai 7y agoThere's just so much to listen to besides music.
- MS90 7y agoThat, and also the fact that services like Spotify/Netflix/Amazon/etc. allow you to access everything for a flat monthly fee. Back in the day you had to buy each album individually for $10-$15 (or more) each, same with movies. Nowadays I can go on Netflix and watch what would've been hundreds or thousands of dollars worth of DVDs for 13 bucks a month.
- ecmascript 7y agoWell, with the advent of internet and better computers I guess producing music and distributing it became so much cheaper and faster the price dropped. Since also many (like me) pirated their way in their teens I never purchased many cds. I got an mp3 early from japan with 512mb of disk space. This was huge, all my classmates had like 128mb or less. It was clear for me anyway that I would never pay a lot for the music because there was simply no reason to. I haven't really experienced the time where it was a norm to spend a lot of money on cds. I am 29 and this kind of experience you have seems to become more and more uncommon as time passes ;)
- bradstewart 7y agoThis made me remember the days of having to decide which songs to put on my little 128MB Rio MP3 player every week. Such a strange "problem" to think about now.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoare you sure it's the norm? I mean first off Spotify is a service that gets money on a subscription model, airpods are a hardware device, so the people who buy airpods this year and that have spotify will buy spotify maybe 2 or 3 years before they buy new airpods. Airpods might have captured more of the market this year for headphones than Spotify captures for its market. Finally the people who use Spotify might use multiple services etc. So even if you spend more money on your audio hardware than what you listen to I don't think we know if people actually spend more on their hardware than on what they listen to.
- gowld 7y agoLooking back on Discman, iPod, stereo receivers, car stereos, speaker setups, and the golden age of kazaa and torrents, I think most people spend more on audio hardware than content, but ad revenue makes it competitive.
- bdcravens 7y agoThere’s more headphone options than Spotify option, and many of those options are less than AirPods or what you’d spend on Spotify in a year.
- LadyCailin 7y agoIt’s free without ads, but is it ethical? That’s the larger question to be asked. Say what you will about how big a cut the corporations get vs the artists, but you’re taking the service without paying for it, directly or indirectly. I hate ads just as much as you, but I also pay for most of the media I consume regularly, be it spotify, newspapers, even youtube, I contribute to various youtuber’s patreons. All in all I probably spend no more that $30 a month on these subscriptions, all ad free, and helping to ensure that the media I love can continue to be offered at reasonable prices. If you can’t afford it, that’s one thing, but you said you can, so...
- gdubs 7y agoAlso, given Apple’s famously wide margins on products, it’s interesting to consider profitability and not just overall revenue.
- awinder 7y agoOh if you started getting into profit you'd be able to stuff tons of companies into the "made more than" bucket, considering that Spotify has had 3 profitable quarters ever, twitter ebbs and flows between profitable and loss quarters, snapchat still isn't profitable. Shopify seems to be a bit more dependable with profits though, so hooray for them.
- ogre_codes 7y agoThere's never been any disclosure of AirPod margins, it's lumped into a big group of other products including Apple Watch, Apple TV, and Beats. Based on the slow production ramp up of the AirPods (they were selling them as fast as they could produce them) and competitor pricing on competitive hardware, there was a lot of conjecture that for the first year or so AirPods were sold at break even. Of course, that was nearly 3 years ago so it's almost certain margins have improved on what is essentially the same product, but I suspect Apple's margins on these are not as high as for the iPhone or iPad. Spotify's big problem is they sell a product which is 99% commodity. Anyone with enough money can create a music streaming service and all resellers pay very similar rates for the same content. Apple Music, Amazon's music, and Google's music all sell the same essential thing. Spotify's only chance for turning their product into a premium (thus profit generating) service is building a significantly better playlist and music recommendation service.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ksec 7y ago>here was a lot of conjecture that for the first year or so AirPods were sold at break even. Oh hell no. That was started by DaringFireball John Gruber. When we talk about margins it is important to note most would refer or implies this as Gross Profit Margin. Which is without the R&D and Marketing Cost, since these are fixed cost, i.e They are the same irrespective of how many unit were sold. All the Audio Gear ( Or Accessories ) sold on the market has some of the highest Gross Profits Margin. Much higher than iPhone or Mac because they were never meant to be sold in huge quantities. Beats, and Apple AirPod were the only two Audio gear that manage to sell in volume. I would be surprised if the BOM cost of AirPods is higher than $20. ( You could get a replica of AirPod without W1 Chip from Shenzhen for less than $10, $8 in thousands of unit, so I am already add lots of headroom in my BOM estimate. ) The major cost is developing W1 Chip and Speaker R&D. Which needs to amortised over unit volume. And AirPods did that spectacularly well.
- mcguire 7y agoI get that AirPods are designed to be replaced frequently, but geeze, is this sustainable?
- judge2020 7y agoI don't think they're made to be replaced, it's more a side-effect of the battery being smaller and more susceptible to wear. The original airpods I got 2 years ago still work for about an hour and do fine.
- dwild 7y ago> The original airpods I got 2 years ago still work for about an hour and do fine. In 2 years the battery life fall to 1 hour? This is just crazy unsustainable!
- etrk 7y agoAs a counter-point, I'm running on 3 years and still get a few hours out of mine. The gamechanger for AirPods was the convenience of the charging case. I'm just surprised I've never run them through the wash.
- wil421 7y agoSame here, 2+ year old AirPods that still hold charge for about an hour. I’ve used them heavily in the first year and still average about 3-4 hours a week for conference calls and a couple more hours of music. In the first year I was using them 3-4 hours per day, sometimes even more.
- rorykoehler 7y agoIf that's the case why isn't the battery replaceable. I spent less money on way better audio quality headphones (Sennheiser HD25) over 20 years ago and they are still going strong. So far I replaced the cable once and the ear pads every few years. Though I would like to buy airpod pros for traveling I cannot bring myself to buy something that will last only 2 years. That is a disgusting example of inbuilt obsolescence and should actually be illegal to sell.