3 ms·
Except for all those times that scientists went beyond their model and overturned the previous models. Overturned scientific models: Lyellian uniformitarianism
by eesmith 7y ago
Except for all those times that scientists went beyond their model and overturned the previous models.
Overturned scientific models: Lyellian uniformitarianism, the pre-Agassiz model that the Earth was gradually cooling so Ice Ages couldn't have existed (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_age#History_of_research https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_age#History_of_research ), Newton's theory of gravitation, and classical statistical mechanics (the "ultraviolet catastrophe").
Plus, the wide-spread belief that "all models are wrong" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_models_are_wrong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_models_are_wrong - or the modified "all models are wrong, but some are useful".
Which doesn't match the dogmatism attributed to religion, does it?
- dnautics 7y agoWell yeah, but those are all rather old results.
- eesmith 7y agoAnd your username contains three vowels. That is, I fail to see what your comment adds to the topic of how dogmatism in science is equal to that of religion, causing scientists to be too afraid to go beyond their model. I'll cherry pick some titles from the 9000+ results of a search for "a new model" on Goggle Scholar for the last year, at https://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_ylo=2019&q=%22a+new+model+for%22&hl=en&as_sdt=0,5 https://scholar.google.com/scholar?as_ylo=2019&q=%22a+new+mo... : > A new model for the biochemistry of pectin synthesis: GAUTs synthesize diverse HG glycans in structurally and functionally distinct plant cell wall polymers > The needle model: A new model for the main hydration peak of alite > Barriers to Hydraulic Fracture Height Growth: A New Model for Sliding Interfaces > A new model for MR evaluation of liver function with gadoxetic acid, including both uptake and excretion > A new model for esker formation sheds light on the processes within subglacial tunnels > Theorizing Transgender Identity for Clinical Practice: A New Model for Understanding Gender > Mutation of Murine Rpl5 reveals a New Model for Diamond Blackfan Anemia Characterized By Defective Erythropoiesis How do I conclude that scientists are too afraid to go beyond their existing models?
- dnautics 7y agoIt's salient to the topic because the blog post title implies a recent shift in the scientific zeitgeist. You cherry-picked three examples from the deep past. And look at your random examples: not a single physics article, and at least half of the 'new models' are in fields where so very little is known anyways that a new model is a low bar. I won't say science is as dogmatic as religion, but it's far far more dogmatic than most practicing scientists would like to admit, which itself is more so than the 'lay person' or policymaker realizes.
- eesmith 7y agorafaelvasco top-level comment started "Not entirely related with the article" so I don't think it's clear what can or cannot be inferred based on the blog post title. "And look at your random examples" Okay, then to focus just on physics for the last 12 months: https://arxiv.org/search/advanced?advanced=&terms-0-operator=AND&terms-0-term=%22a+new+model%22&terms-0-field=all&classification-physics=y&classification-physics_archives=all&classification-include_cross_list=include&date-filter_by=all_dates&date-year=&date-from_date=&date-to_date=&date-date_type=submitted_date&abstracts=show&size=50&order=-announced_date_first https://arxiv.org/search/advanced?advanced=&terms-0-operator... > Bremsstrahlung emission of photons during nuclear reactions inside dense stellar medium is investigated in the paper. For that, a new model of nucleus is developed, where nuclear forces combine nucleons as bound system in dependence on deep location inside compact star. > Therefore Monte Carlo generators, like the TAUOLA program, have to facilitate precision analysis as well as confront new models that constantly emerge with the availability of high statistics experimental data. > Dust moments: towards a new modelling of the galactic dust emission for CMB B-modes analysis > We introduce a new model for a pairwise repulsive interaction potential of vortices in a type-II superconductor, consisting of superimposed six- and 12-fold anisotropies. You write "I won't say science is as dogmatic as religion" But that's the argument that rafaelvasco made, and what I was objecting to. > it's far far more dogmatic than most practicing scientists would like to admit Can you present any evidence of that? Certainly there's the 1950 quote by Max Planck "This experience gave me also an opportunity to learn a fact - a remarkable one, in my opinion: A new scientific truth does not triumph, by convincing, its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it." or the more succinct quip "Science progresses one funeral at a time" already brought up on this thread. But the widespread reference to that idea suggests that many practicing scientists admit there is dogmatism. And there are plenty of examples. One I learned in the 1990s was about H. pylori. Quoting https://www.discovermagazine.com/health/the-doctor-who-drank-infectious-broth-gave-himself-an-ulcer-and-solved-a-medical-mystery https://www.discovermagazine.com/health/the-doctor-who-drank... > The medical elite thought they knew what caused ulcers and stomach cancer. But they were wrong—and didn't want to hear otherwise. Again, these stories go around, so I don't agree with your exaggerated "far far more dogmatic" statement.
- empath75 7y agoNewton’s theory of gravitation wasn’t tossed out; general relativity produces Newtonian gravity within certain parameters. Lots of theories are perfectly valid in a limited domain, while not being “fundamental”.
- eesmith 7y agoI said nothing about "tossed out". The topic concerns scientists going "beyond" the model Your true statements about Newtonian gravity is aptly described by the last quote I gave - "All models are wrong, but some are useful".