2 ms·
I think there is an issue of mismatched expectations. Logicomix is just a divulgative effort that briefly surveys Russell’s life. As somebody with little knowle
by toyg 7y ago
I think there is an issue of mismatched expectations. Logicomix is just a divulgative effort that briefly surveys Russell’s life. As somebody with little knowledge of post-Enlightenment philosophy, I honestly did not come away from it thinking philosophers were mad, but simply that his gallant effort in logicism reached the end of the line once Gödel entered the scene - which is what happened, by all accounts. He looked extremely reasonable, particularly considering how his whole prestige and career depended on the methods Gödel wiped away.
If i remember correctly (been a while since I read it), Logicomix really failed to explain how Russell went on to become relevant in public discourse at large, basically assuming that philosophers are interesting by default... I bought it mostly to find that out (he was very influential on my parents’ generation, as one of the classic intellectuals mentioned in ‘68 movements) and was somehow disappointed to just get the story of a logician instead. Still, it was a coherent story with great reverence for its subject, IMHO. Had it been trying even harder to delve into logic, as you expected, I would have probably thrown it out of the window.