3 ms·
> ... but the question is why wouldn't you want to make the changes to target zero deaths? Well, if you target "zero" of anything with a large enough N, you en
by arcticbull 7y ago
> ... but the question is why wouldn't you want to make the changes to target zero deaths?
Well, if you target "zero" of anything with a large enough N, you end up well past the point of diminishing returns, and avoiding that last death may have a price tag truly outsized relative to the benefit. It may even cause more deaths in other areas.
For instance, after 9/11 security at airports was tightened massively ("targeting zero") and this caused a lot more people to drive short distances, which is much riskier than flying, which in turn caused way, way more deaths than all of 9/11. Micro, achieved, macro, failed.
Bruce Schneier covers this well in an essay titled "Our Decreasing Tolerance to Risk" [1]
With that in mind, I don't believe cars should exist in urban centers, but because they're a livability nightmare rather than due to the very low risk cars pose to my continued existence (you have a 0.01%/year chance of dying in a fatal car accident).
[1] https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2013/08/our_decreasing_toler.html https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2013/08/our_decreas...
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> you have a 0.01%/year chance of dying in a fatal car accident Which sounds like very little. But life expectancy is now around 80 years. That means that your lifetime chance of dying in a car accident is 0.8%. That's high enough that, in a country of 330 million people, it adds up to a problem that's worth trying to solve. Look, I mostly agree with you. But the "low risk" argument in your last paragraph isn't as effective as you think.