4 ms·
It's like "zero crime" --- you end up with authoritarian dystopia. IMNSHO extremism in all forms is not a good thing, no matter what the cause. There's plenty o
by userbinator 7y ago
It's like "zero crime" --- you end up with authoritarian dystopia. IMNSHO extremism in all forms is not a good thing, no matter what the cause. There's plenty of sci-fi on that topic.
I find it ironic that HN seems to be both very pro-freedom/privacy/right-to-repair, yet also very anti-car. Perhaps two separate demographics.
- wutbrodo 7y agoDo you feel the same way about zero polio deaths? The transportation issue is fairly complicated, and there does exist a tendency to oversimplify the costs of moving away from the status quo. But many of the reactions on this thread (this one included) are even more free of nuance or an attempt at understanding the situation. There's no question for anyone who's bothered to inform themselves that the US status quo around transportation is far from ideal for most sets of preferences[1]. Vision Zero is a bit of a blunt instrument for calling attention to how bad the status quo is, but it's a lot better than the arguments I'm seeing here. [1] Obviously you can construct a set of preferences that is optimal for a given state, but I'm using reasonable priors here.
- arcticbull 7y agoZero polio is a cut/dried thing. We know how much the polio vaccine costs to manufacture, we know the risk of adverse side effect (very low) and we can administer the vaccines alongside your normal check-ups. You're not increasing the risk of death due to something else by decreasing the risk of polio.
- 29083011397778 7y ago> I find it ironic that HN seems to be both very pro-freedom/privacy/right-to-repair, yet also very anti-car. Perhaps two separate demographics. I suspect there's less overlap than you assume. Freedom I'm sure we could go back and forth on for hours (money has better uses than gas IMO, but the freedom of a car is undeniable), but privacy for cars is an unmitigated disaster. Government-issued ID is undoubtedly a good requirement for driving, but everything else, from automatic license plate scanners to cars frequently reporting your location (to On-Star or Honda's anti-theft) leaves privacy in a dismal state. Right to Repair is moving the wrong way as cars move from mechanical to digital. Tesla is infamous for this, and moving more people to electric cars seems unlikely to reverse the trend. We're also discussing a subset of people likely sitting at desks far too much. I don't want to sit all day then sit in a car to get home either.