4 ms·
Most (~70%) Americans live in cities. It’s an overwhelmingly urban country. https://www.citylab.com/equity/2012/03/us-urban-population-what-does-urban-really-
by mulmen 7y ago
Most (~70%) Americans live in cities. It’s an overwhelmingly urban country.
https://www.citylab.com/equity/2012/03/us-urban-population-what-does-urban-really-mean/1589/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2012/03/us-urban-population-w...
- pdonis 7y agoThat doesn't give the 70% the right to dictate to the 30% who don't live in cities how they should live. Nor do they need to. There's no reason why different environments can't address whatever problems they see in different ways. We don't need to force everyone to live the way people who live in cities live.
- ogre_codes 7y agoVery very few people advocate for eliminating every single car. Generally discussions about car-free infra are about places where cars have saturated the public infrastructure making it nearly impossible to safely move around any other way. Car free infrastructure is about growth and quality of life in dense urban areas. It doesn't make sense to eliminate cars from rural or even most suburban areas.
- pdonis 7y ago> Car free infrastructure is about growth and quality of life in dense urban areas. Not according to the article. It specifically talks about the Boston suburbs, for example.
- ogre_codes 7y agoThe article also doesn't talk about eliminating cars, in fact it very specifically has recommendations about how car traffic should be handled.
- pdonis 7y ago> The article also doesn't talk about eliminating cars I didn't say it did.
- arcticbull 7y agoIs the 70% dictating to the 30% not the definition of democracy? They do have the right, but of course, that doesn't make it right. Further, the 70% who live in urban areas largely generate the money thats spent on the 30% living outside. Were interstates self-sufficient you may have had a stronger point. Cars should probably be banned from urban centers entirely, replaced with investments in public transport, in walkability and in bikes. Cars outside the urban areas, well, it's not clear.
- pdonis 7y ago> Is the 70% dictating to the 30% not the definition of democracy? One kind of democracy, perhaps, but not the kind I support. Tyranny of the majority is not a good thing. > the 70% who live in urban areas largely generate the money thats spent on the 30% living outside Excuse me? Productive citizens don't only live in urban areas.
- arcticbull 7y ago> One kind of democracy, perhaps, but not the kind I support. Tyranny of the majority is not a good thing. Indeed, I was just responding to the "they don't have the right" -- they do. It's not a good look to exercise it, though. > Excuse me? Productive citizens don't only live in urban areas. Of course, although the work they do is valued lower in the modern US economy which tends to be services-driven and not resource-driven. Further, there's nothing you can do to make up for the economic power of population density, efficiencies re: economies of scale, and the kinds of work that are most rewarded. US metro economies account for 90.8% of GDP, 91.3% of wage income, and 87.7% of jobs. [1] This means that it accounts for easily over 90% of tax revenue, which in turn means that it accounts for easily over 90% of infrastructure spending on things like interstates. More so as the median income is almost 50% higher in metros than outside, which means the marginal tax rates are higher, too. [1] http://css.umich.edu/factsheets/us-cities-factsheet http://css.umich.edu/factsheets/us-cities-factsheet
- pdonis 7y ago> I was just responding to the "they don't have the right" -- they do. No, they don't. They might have the power, in theory, but that doesn't mean they have the right.
- mulmen 7y agoThe 70% aren’t dictating how to live to the other 30%. Who is suggesting that? This article is about reducing road deaths. Nobody is asking people in rural areas to live like they are in cities.
- pdonis 7y ago> The 70% aren’t dictating how to live to the other 30%. Then why are you pointing out what percentage of people live in urban areas?
- mulmen 7y ago> Mass transit is important in cities, but lots of Americans, probably most, live where cars are needed to get around. Because the "probably most" part is not true. Although I admit that public transit is lacking in many cities in the country, a huge number of Americans live in areas that could support mass transit. I don't live in those places so I will reserve judgement and let them make their own choices. I already moved to a city, they can do what they want.
- asdff 7y agoNothing is going to change for the rural areas. All these articles are about urban areas that really could use some transit as they gridlock daily. LA or Boise, all major cities have shit rush hour traffic.
- medymed 7y agoIn this article small towns are counted as ‘urban’, including areas with 2500 people. The main point of the article is the metric used to get 70% is not really what we think of as a urban city but anything from tiny towns to big cities. The real ‘city-folk’ number of downtown-dwellers is much much smaller, they suggest around half of total ‘urban’ dwellers.
- mulmen 7y ago> There are officially two types of urban areas: “urbanized areas” of 50,000 or more people and “urban clusters” of between 2,500 and 50,000 people. For the 2010 count, the Census Bureau has defined 486 urbanized areas, accounting for 71.2 percent of the U.S. population. The 3,087 urban clusters account for 9.5 percent of the U.S. population. Maybe I misread that but I parsed it as ~70% of people live in “Urbanized Areas” which have populations over 50,000.
- falcolas 7y ago50,000 people is still a relatively tiny city. As I noted separately, my town qualifies, and we don’t have public transportation (and rightly so: there’s too much space and nothing to transport people to).
- medymed 7y agoI agree. What’s really weird is that for example downtown Dallas has a population of 10-11k people, with a density of 7,690 per square mile. That number feels almost rural compared to here in Manhattan at 66,940 per sq mile.
- melq 7y agoI grew up in a town with nearly double that in population, and if you didn’t have a car you were screwed. Barely any public transportation to speak of besides an inadequate amount of bus routes that ran far too infrequently. Most of the major shopping and commercial areas don’t even have sidewalks on the streets. Only the relatively small downtown area could be considered pedestrian friendly and that area provides very few jobs comparatively.
- falcolas 7y agoBy that definition of urban, I live in an urban environment. We don’t have a public transport system. A sizable percentage of children who attend the local school can’t take a school bus to school - too much distance with too few busses and drivers. We’re unusually lucky in that we have two grocery stores, across the street from each other. One survives solely on good will from people who don’t want to visit that “interloping big city chain” that’s been here for two decades now. There’s another city nine miles down the road that also matches this description, but they only have one grocery store, and its poorly enough stocked that they come over here for many of their more esoteric needs, like spices. But they also have a really good steak house, so they have that going for them. Another nine miles brings you to another “urban” center. They have a grocery store, but it’s even smaller. And they don’t have a good steak house. Urban. To poorly quote a movie: “I don’t think that word means quite what you think it means.”
- mulmen 7y agoAccording to https://www2.census.gov/geo/pdfs/reference/GARM/Ch12GARM.pdf https://www2.census.gov/geo/pdfs/reference/GARM/Ch12GARM.pdf density is also included in the definition. Skimming it seems like generally a place with 1000 people or more per square mile qualifies as "urban". That's still awfully low population density but it does clarify that not all towns over 2500 people are automatically defined as "urban". Similarly it is possible to have a population over 50,000 and not be "urban". Is your town on this list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_urban_areas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_urban_ar...? But none of that says anything about public transit. According to https://www.ptua.org.au/myths/density/ https://www.ptua.org.au/myths/density/ public transit becomes viable at around 13.5 people per hectare which by my back of the envelope math works out to about 3400 people per square mile. Taking that back to the Wikipedia article there are 75,000,000 people living in areas with enough density to support public transit. It is worth noting that cities with current, working public transit systems (like Seattle, WA and Boston, MA) do not meet the 3,400 people per square mile requirement. If we add up all the peopple living in urban areas with density equal to or greater than Boston we get 148,744,607. If we add up everyone living in Charlotte, NC (which has a public transit system) or denser we get 196,307,807 people! This is all obviously a massive oversimplification and we can argue in circles forever. The point is that by the US Census Bureau definition most Americans live in "Urban" areas (for a fairly clear definition of "Urban" and "in") and that we can probably support a lot more public transit.