3 ms·
I haven't finished reading the article yet, but this strikes me as a classic example of innapropriate generalization. The hip-hop culture example seems to rein
by ajross 18y ago
I haven't finished reading the article yet, but this strikes me as a classic example of innapropriate generalization. The hip-hop culture example seems to reinforce the argument, but many other subcultures fail: think of the french aristocracy in the 18th century as a classic example of conspicuous consumption. Or the roaring 20's. Or various calvinist groups of the 17th century as examples of the austere poor. Or...
The point being that the variation in visible consumption between groups is vast, and this article picked just two groups two compare. It's junk science. And IMHO, it's borderline racist.
- Retric 18y agoI haven't finished reading the article yet Keep reading. The same is true for whites. Controlling for differences in housing costs, an increase of $10,000 in the mean income for white households—about like going from South Carolina to California—leads to a 13 percent decrease in spending on visible goods. “Take a $100,000-a-year person in Alabama and a $100,000 person in Boston,” says Hurst. “The $100,000 person in Alabama does more visible consumption than the $100,000 person in Massachusetts.” That’s why a diamond-crusted Rolex screams “nouveau riche.” It signals that the owner came from a poor group and has something to prove.
- pchristensen 18y agoBoston has way more much richer people, so showing off with stuff like a Rolex won't do much good. Your $10K watch isn't that impressive if there are people that could buy the watch company.
- maw 18y agoIndeed. On the other hand, while somebody who makes $100k and lives in Boston won't exactly be struggling to make ends meet, he'll have a lot less money to spend frivolously than somebody making that much in Alabama.
- cconstantine 18y agoI recommend reading the article before discarding it for being junk science or borderline racist. You may discard it for those reasons after reading it if you wish... but I doubt you will. Blacks are poorer (on average) than whites. That's a simple correlation and it says nothing about why black people are poorer. They also looked at the data in a way that eliminates race as a variable and found the same patterns. I'd say it was a good read.
- pxlpshr 18y agoI agree with the comments already made in regard to your post above. Here are a few of my own: If you're going to point to the early 20's and the like as a parallel (a time when economic prosperity was high), then I beg you to compare tribal behavior in Africa, and consumption habits within Latin America where economic prosperity is extremely low across the board. However, I am partially in agreement with the context of your post. MTV/VH1 has been destructive in the picture it paints of meaningful wealth, and I feel media has played a significant factor in "keeping up with the Jones" to the masses. Before the 90's, exposure to this type of wealth-behavior was relatively contained. In retrospect, the credit crunch has hyper-inflated our economy and caused businesses to scale up while a tidal wave formed below. I can't tell you how many people I know that are living a facade, white, black, and brown. It's sad really. On a side note: That picture has to be Cris Angel's hand. I want to know which Vegas tycoon thought he was a good idea. slap