3 ms·
The Billion-Dollar Battle over .Org
- ohashi 7y agoI'd like more details about who is behind it and what their goals are. But it sounds better than Ethos at its core. The fact it's not being run for profit puts motives well above Ethos who pretend 10% per year price increases are reasonable and accepted. ORG hasn't raised prices in years and hasn't had a need to. It was one of the arguments for uncapping the price is that they were a responsible steward not taking advantage of their annual 10%, so why would it be abused? A PE company acquiring it is exactly why. If Internet Society imploded and had contract taken away and their revenue stream of .ORG revoked it would be karma for selling out the community they were supposed to represent. I suspect if this were to happen the new COOP would be required to supplement ISOC budget at least for a while. But personally, I would love to see ISOC get nothing. It should be a harsh reminder that representing your community properly is important.
- eps 7y agoDid I miss it or they don't at all mention the blatantly obvious arms length distance between this 2-person newly formed Ethos and ICANN?
- ohashi 7y agoNot mentioned.
- OskarS 7y agoThese kinds of statements are infuriating: > Ethos Capital has pledged to adhere to the 10 percent cap, though it would have no contractual obligation to do so. In blog posts, the private equity firm said it planned to invest in new services and clamp down on spam, security attacks and other abuse launched from some illicit dot-org domains. Like, is there any person in the universe who is naive enough to believe that the motives of a private equity company are totally pure and just about making the web better? It's a private equity company: OF COURSE they are buying it so that they can milk as much cash as possible out of the sale, with absolutely zero concern what's best for the "health of the internet" or whatever. That is their reason for existing. Pretending that this is anything other than a private entity trying to profit at the expense of the public is ludicrous.
- ohashi 7y agoJust look at what the defenders are saying on ICANN mailing lists. You can't assume ill intent from Ethos they say, they could do a better job than ISOC for all we know. It's a bullshit argument coming from registry lobbyists and ISOC members. And they throw out 10% annual price increases per year like it's normal. Since 2003, .ORG has had 7 price increases at 2.5, 10, 7, 3.5, 7, 10, 10 (percent). Which is an average of 7.5% per price increases, which have happened every 2.4 years. So an annual 10% price increase is well out of line with the norm.