5 ms·
Wildlife population demographic estimates are generally unreliable, even in the best of conditions. In the a well-conducted survey, the 95% confidence interval
by jcranmer 7y ago
Wildlife population demographic estimates are generally unreliable, even in the best of conditions. In the a well-conducted survey, the 95% confidence interval is going to be an order of magnitude--e.g., 10-100.
The number that's thrown out here is not strongly sourced, but given that it's in response to an ongoing event, I suspect that it comes from "take a stab at animals per hectare, multiply times number of hectares burned, and round up to next round number to maximize outrage." Or maybe it will be slightly more accurate, with someone taking the time to dig up some numbers from a prior survey to estimate population differences per biome and tracking down how much of each biome has died.
Which is a long-winded way of saying that these estimates (almost certainly) are not reliable.
Edit: someone else linked the source. The number turns out to be "number of animals per hectare * hectares burned." I still stand by my verdict of not reliable, as there is not an even an indication of what the range of uncertainty is in this information, just a single number.
- jtms 7y agoUnless I am misunderstanding, this method assumes that all animals per hectare are non-mobile and do not run from fire. The impact from loss of habitat/starvation may end up making the numbers not far off though.
- jcranmer 7y agoThat is my understanding as well--the actual source states "affected" instead of "died." I have yet to see anyone actually give a reliable estimation of how to turn "affected" into "died", and I can sustain arguments for anything between 1% and 100%. There are essentially three pieces of information going into this estimate: pre-fire density, fire acreage, and fire mortality (in the long run). The first number is known at best to an order of magnitude, the second is quite well-known (thanks to satellites), and the last appears to be unknown.
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoThat assumption is not totally insane these fires are often moving at around 60km/h. Also from the videos I have seen you can see huge pile ups of burned animal bodies stuck on fences.
- girvo 7y agoThese fires catch people in cars. Running from them? You’re kidding I hope, or at least speaking from ignorance.