3 ms·
It was a complete and utter waste of time, as has been every other performance review I have ever been a part of. Performance reviews from bosses are almost al
by musicale 7y ago
It was a complete and utter waste of time, as has been every other performance review I have ever been a part of.
Performance reviews from bosses are almost always useless and do more harm than good. The only possible exception I've seen might be in research settings where supervisors sometimes work closely with you and may actually be qualified to evaluate your work. But in that case, usually they are already giving you feedback during the process and a formal performance review is just a checkbox item to satisfy their own supervisor or funding organization.
Moreover it is generally impossible to have a fair and honest discussion with someone who can fire you or influence your pay.
Actual feedback on your work from skilled technical people on your team and actual users is generally far more useful than a performance review and can be gathered at any time.
- perl4ever 7y agoWell, I can't say I have ever had a performance review that was inspiring or useful, but it's kind of depressing when you start out having them and then stop. Because one of the subtexts is, why even pretend we might give you a raise? And it means you're unlikely to be fired, but it also means nobody even cares enough to do something about anyone that is causing problems.
- downerending 7y agoThey are good for one thing: If your manager says anything other than "Keep up the good work!", you know that (a) they don't like you, and (b) they're working on getting rid of you. Extremely valuable information if you know what to do with it.
- suchire 7y ago”But in that case, usually they are already giving you feedback during the process and a formal performance review is just a checkbox item to satisfy their own supervisor or funding organization” If this is ever not true of your manager at any company in any industry, then the manager sucks and you should leave (if you have the means). If the manager wants to do this but the company doesn’t let them, then the CEO suck and you should leave.