3 ms·
> It took an Einstein of the time to figure out things could even be planted. It is a monumental achievement. Not just that. But someone had to invent: * Pott
by dragontamer 7y ago
> It took an Einstein of the time to figure out things could even be planted. It is a monumental achievement.
Not just that. But someone had to invent:
* Pottery (Lets store food, instead of looking for it all the time)
* Writing
* Cities (Hey, lets all settle here and come back here for some reason)
* Law
* Basic tools: Rope, Hammer, Wedge, Knife. Metallurgy.
If we were trapped in a hunter-gatherer society, even with our advanced brains today... it would take a very smart person to invent a city and/or writing. And you'd need the support of the entire hunter-gatherer society to bring you food and resources to fund the inventions.
Cities invent the aristocracy, a group of people who are dedicated to advancement of culture and technology. Agriculture and Pottery provide a way for transportation and storage of resources (food especially), supporting the aristocracy.
At which point, true inventions can begin. You can't invent new tools if you're too busy hunting for food every day of your life.
- WalterBright 7y ago> You can't invent new tools if you're too busy hunting for food every day of your life. Even the spear-thrower, followed by the bow and arrow, took a loooooong time to invent.
- dragontamer 7y agoIIRC, many Europeans were throwing Axes in the Dark Ages, just ~1500 years ago. Even if the bow was invented, creating good fetching and requiring the mass production of fragile arrows makes it a poor weapon in the Dark ages. You pretty much have to invent mass production + commodities, standardizing the arrowhead before Bows become superior to spear and/or axe throwing. Once "any" arrow can work on "any" bow, you are golden. But this commodity idea is very difficult to come up with. Shoot an arrow into a deer, and the arrow is ruined. You need to build a new arrow. Throw a javelin or Axe into a deer, and you can use the same Javelin / Axe on the next deer as well.
- WalterBright 7y agoNot buying it :-) 1. arrows are reusable. I've dabbled in archery. 2. arrows are a distance weapon. You can take out prey or enemy at a distance. Throwing an axe is very short range. 3. throwing an axe means you get one shot. Then you're weaponless. 4. throwing a metal axe is much more effective than a stone axe. I seriously doubt throwing a stone axe is very effective - you'd be better off just throwing a rock.
- dragontamer 7y ago> 3. throwing an axe means you get one shot. Then you're weaponless. Romans carried 2 Pilum, a shortsword, and a shield. You had two shots, after which you rushed in with your swords. Yeah, Longbowmen are obviously superior. But if you have 10,000 Longbowmen with 60 arrows per man, you require a production-capacity of 60,000 arrows per battle. That's a lot of goose feathers, even if you're recycling a significant chunk of arrows. Note that the modern arrow has fletching for accuracy. Ancient arrows didn't have fletching: no spin, no accuracy. Before the middle ages, mass production of arrows in this capacity was basically impossible. The British innovation to war wasn't so much the Longbow (there were plenty of archers before the British...), it was the invention of commodity mass produced arrows... which supported the Longbowman as a major unit of warfare. Even the Roman Legionaries used Pilum (aka: Javelins) as their ranged weapon of choice. Bows existed (see the Sagittarii), but were an auxiliary (and often non-Roman) force. ------------ Slingers (!!) were still used in Roman times. Now a Sling... THAT is an ideal ancient weapon. A trained slinger can kill a Lion or Bear, and you only had to find rocks to throw. Mass production of sling-bullets (really, just a shaped rock) is easy, even with an army marching to a distant location. Slingers used rocks, clay, and even lead bullets throughout history. They were effectively the longbowmen before the British learned to mass produce arrows. In fact, the ancient world believed that Slings had greater range and accuracy than bows. Since fletching won't be invented for another 1000+ years, ancient arrows had very limited range and accuracy.
- WalterBright 7y ago> Ancient arrows didn't have fletching: no spin, no accuracy. I couldn't find any mention of when spin was added. But I would think it pretty darned hard to align the feathers so precisely that it wouldn't spin anyway. Bird feathers aren't straight, either. Arrows date back 64,000 years (wikipedia). A long time before the Romans. Equipping 10,000 soldiers with any sort of kit will be a major undertaking. Most any bird feathers can be used for arrows. Not just goose.