3 ms·
I have pretty much given up on Arduino. They had me almost interested again when they announced the Pro IDE, but several months later they still haven't put th
by jrockway 7y ago
I have pretty much given up on Arduino. They had me almost interested again when they announced the Pro IDE, but several months later they still haven't put the source code on Github: https://github.com/arduino/arduino-pro-ide https://github.com/arduino/arduino-pro-ide
I am not interested in the Electron-based IDE, but they seem to be using the Clang language server, which is perfect for integrating with Emacs. I have been sitting here for months ready to hack on this stuff and make it work perfectly, but all I have to work with is the raw source files contained in the Electron bundle with no license, so I've basically given up. Once again, the Arduino team is doing Weird Stuff with software, and this whole Pro thing feels like "the joys of working with Broadcom, but we stick random Open Source logos on thing without actually being Open Source".
I have a lot of microcontroller projects I want to do, but without modern development tools, it's not worth it. They are so close... just let me hack on your source code, please. I'll do it for free and you can do whatever you want with the code. But they don't seem to want to play ball.
(Recently I have been playing with Tinygo, but I am still not motivated because "go doc", my favorite go tool, and gopls don't work... and I'm not quite sure that it's worth the effort to make work yet. My toy tinygo projects have gone pretty well, though, so maybe it is worth making their IDE support work, and forgetting Arduino ever existed. I feel like Circuit Python / Micropython is the path of least resistance right now.)
- HeyLaughingBoy 7y agoYou can use Visual Studio/VS Code with plugins like (free) VisualMicros or (paid) VisualGDB to build Arduino C++ in a much better environment.
- noodlesUK 7y agoPlatformio is also a good choice.
- vineyardmike 7y agoPlatformio is definitely what I’d recommend using. It’s been the best experience I’ve had so far
- elcritch 7y agoToo bad regarding the Arduino pro IDE. There’s so much room for improvement in microcontroller space. If you can use a Linux based SBC you might check out Nerves (nerves-project.org/). It’s nice for a lot of “one off” projects and with boards like orange pi zero, pi zero, etc the cost isn’t bad. I’m working on support for Omega2+ boards which are pretty low power and have decent WiFi. Still they’re not as suitable for low power, really small size, or real time projects. For microcontrollers, Rust seems to have decent support for a few of the STM boards. I’ve been tempted.
- _alex_ 7y agoYou have lots of microcontroller projects you want to do, but can't because you can't get up to date source on the arduino IDE? wat? Just use a different editor.
- jrockway 7y agoI have other stuff to do, and the prerequisite to any microcontroller project is to spend a week fighting with tools. So I just don't care enough.
- codebje 7y agoGet an STM32 "pill" board, platform.io in VSCode or any way you like to write C using CubeMX to generate a project structure, then Make to build and flash. STM HAL isn't exactly great either, but Arduino is best placed IMO as entry level novice stuff, or blasting out something working in five minutes.