3 ms·
Just to clarify, the scope of the article is state and local tax incentives. The federal government has many more tax incentives (basically anything that you ca
by gnicholas 7y ago
Just to clarify, the scope of the article is state and local tax incentives. The federal government has many more tax incentives (basically anything that you can get a deduction or credit for), and these definitely shape behavior because the rate is so much higher than state/local taxes.
Perhaps the title could be updated to say "state/local tax incentives".
- boomboomsubban 7y ago>these definitely shape behavior because the rate is so much higher than state/local taxes. Evidence for this claim? Although you're right that the article is about state/local taxes, it's not obvious that federal tax breaks are different.
- gnicholas 7y agoWell, I worked as a corporate tax lawyer for the better part of a decade, and I could see how companies did or did not react to tax incentives. The higher the rate is, the more companies are willing to bend behavior to qualify for it. I can't cite specifics due to confidentiality, but it is universally accepted among tax practitioners and scholars that deductions are move valuable when rates are higher. Credits don't scale this way because they're a dollar-for-dollar tax reduction (although they're still limited to the total amount of tax that would be paid).
- boomboomsubban 7y agoFrom what I've seen, federal tax is around 1/3rd of the total taxation done,, so I don't see why federal cuts would gain this importance. And it has almost universally been accepted that local and state breaks cause growth, there just isn't evidence that this happens.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> The federal government has many more tax incentives (basically anything that you can get a deduction or credit for), Only credits are really business tax incentives, since business expenses, as such, are generally deductible. > and these definitely shape behavior because the rate is so much higher than state/local taxes That doesn't follow. It would make sense that if state/local incentives did shape behavior, larger federal incentives would do more to shape behavior. But if state/local incentives have no evident effect, what amounts to more of the same could plausibly also have no effect.
- gnicholas 7y ago> Only credits are really business tax incentives Credits are definitely not the only business tax incentives. Accelerated depreciation or amortization is one easy example. Also, the decision to treat something as an immediately-deductible expense as opposed to something that has to be capitalized is itself a tax incentive. > But if state/local incentives have no evident effect, what amounts to more of the same could plausibly also have no effect. Sure, it could. But the paper doesn't even try to establish that. It's like saying that speeding doesn't cause traffic accidents, based on an article that only looked at bicycles that speed. It's a bit odd to have attracted downvotes here, while at the same time the title was updated in the way that I suggested.