3 ms·
Why is Ray Kurzweil's hypothesis particularly important to contrast other hypotheses against? What sets it apart in relevance and/or authority?
by the_af 7y ago
Why is Ray Kurzweil's hypothesis particularly important to contrast other hypotheses against? What sets it apart in relevance and/or authority?
- tlarkworthy 7y agoIt's very well known and makes a compelling argument that tech progress has been accelerating since the Stone age.
- the_af 7y agoI agree Kurzweil's hypothesis is well known... within techie/Silicon Valley circles, somewhat like the Singularity -- a related concept -- is common in those circles as well. Regardless, there's no particular weight to Kurzweil's hypothesis, tantalizing as it may seem, and it's not reasonable in my opinion to use it as a measuring stick of other hypotheses as if Kurzweil was a proven and acknowledged authority on this topic. Likewise, if someone said "human aging and death are unavoidable" this wouldn't be bold just because Kurzweil has written a lot about immortality.
- gfodor 7y agoI think his hypothesis deserves more credit than that — many of his predictions have come to pass, and many of those that have, at the time they were predicted, seemed somewhat far fetched since they were firmly in the realm of science fiction.
- chrisco255 7y agoIt doesn't matter. Each prediction has to be weighed on its own merit against ever-evolving reality. Even Einstein didn't bat a thousand.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWell known is irrelevant. "Has been accelerating" is also irrelevant. Will continue to accelerate to something very close to infinity is the relevant part. There are plenty of us who do not find Kurzweil's argument on that topic to be at all compelling.
- throw_14JAS 7y agoBecause it's evidence is pretty straightforward: you can take wikipedia's list of important inventions and plot their frequency on a chart. Of course, there are debates around which inventions count as significant. And there is recency bias. Never underestimate the power in something easy to communicate.
- beat 7y agoI think population growth also factors in. Population is leveling off. In the past century, the global population has quadrupled, so there are four times as many people to invent things in raw numbers alone. But global population will increase no more than 50% in the next century, which means we aren't creating a lot more inventors than we are now.
- davnicwil 7y agoThis is a good point, but also consider the proportion of the global population who have the opportunity to become inventors is hopefully going to grow over the next century. As a result, the absolute number of inventors may grow faster than by just growing the overall population size.
- the_af 7y ago> "Never underestimate the power in something easy to communicate." Yes, I suppose that's the biggest thing with these "futurologists": their predictions are both tantalizing and easy to digest. I reserve the right to remain skeptical about any of these Silicon Valley religions though.
- tlarkworthy 7y agoU should look him up, futurology is only a slice of Kurzweil's enormous body of innovative work.
- solidasparagus 7y agoKurzweil is someone who does not understand where his expertise ends and makes bogus claims based on a poor understanding of non-computer science topics (see his claims about AGI + the human brain as an example). His claims are typically too generic to be wrong or he does mental gymnastics to claim his prediction was correct when it wasn't. Just read his analysis of how his predictions for 2009 did - https://www.kurzweilai.net/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Faring.pdf https://www.kurzweilai.net/images/How-My-Predictions-Are-Far... He claims he's right even when he's obviously wrong. He is not someone whose predictions should be blindly trusted.