4 ms·
"I'd prefer something owned and operated by the schools themselves." I strongly disagree. Part of the point of these things would be to not be the school, to e
by jerf 16y ago
"I'd prefer something owned and operated by the schools themselves."
I strongly disagree. Part of the point of these things would be to not be the school, to emphatically not be the school. My BBS days would have been much less interesting if everything had to be sanitized for school authority consumption.
At some point children are no longer in school. It would be nice if they have some miniscule amount of experience in being in a not-school environment, what with that making up the majority of their lives. If schools are anything they are already too large, in terms of the footprint they leave on our children's lives.
- michaelchisari 16y agoAfter a certain age, yes, I know I appreciated the freedom of BBS's when I was a teenager as well. But up to around 13, building your social network around your classmates makes sense. And the ability to exclude older children, and non-students, as well as be able to monitor their activity also makes sense. There isn't the strong need for privacy when you're nine than there is when you're 14.
- tptacek 16y agoIn fact, there has already been legal drama with schools objecting to what students write about their classes and teachers and seeking to punish them for it. I agree, affiliation with the school system is a liability, not a benefit.
- michaelchisari 16y agoOlder students would have their school profile, and their non-school profile, just like they have their school email address, and their non-school one. It's really not much different. As to the litigiousness of school administrators around free speech issues, that's something that will have to be worked out with social networking whether schools run their own networks or not. But when you're dealing with the pre-teenager crowd, I don't think it's as much of a legal issue.
- tptacek 16y agoThe teachers at my kids schools don't all use their school email accounts. None of the students I know of do. No, not super interested in waiting for the schools to figure this out, or helping to push them there. I don't know why this should have anything to do with schools; in fact, getting outside the little social circles inside a school is one of the major wins to this.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- michaelchisari 16y agoThat may have more to do with the lack of interest in email that most kids have, than any anti-institutional preference of 8-12 year olds, though.
- tptacek 16y agoNo it doesn't. The teachers use email incessantly. My kids use email regularly.