3 ms·
20ms for playback of media is totally fine. (Hint: If you're standing on the opposite side of the room from a TV, you're already at about 15ms of latency...sou
by TylerE 7y ago
20ms for playback of media is totally fine.
(Hint: If you're standing on the opposite side of the room from a TV, you're already at about 15ms of latency...sound moves at approx. 1ft per ms)
Many TVs are already delaying the audio by a frame or two anyway due to all the processing they do.
It's a very very different set of requirements than real time recording/instrument playback.
- Naac 7y agoThat seems like too much. According to this chart[0], I would say worst case scenario people are sitting 10 feet away from their television. Not to mention 15ms would imply you're 15 feet away, which I don't think is the average room size for most people. I would average worst case scenario would be 10 feet, so 10ms, and average best case would be 3 ms if you're sitting in front of your computer with speakers. [0] https://www.crutchfield.com/S-DxEcQ1ASZo9/learn/learningcenter/home/TV_placement.html https://www.crutchfield.com/S-DxEcQ1ASZo9/learn/learningcent...
- TylerE 7y agoImagine being at the bar or gym, which is the sort of use case being thrown out in this thread. 15ft is low, if anything.
- lightedman 7y ago"20ms for playback of media is totally fine." Not when you're wearing headphones and playing along with the music with your guitar. 20ms is more than enough to throw off even the most professional musician's timing. It's enough to throw off opera orchestral performance (and I've had it happen performing at Forrest Lawn Glen Avon near Walt Disney's tomb.) This is why I'm still using wired headphones. Latency is unacceptable in my hobbies.
- TylerE 7y agoAgain, performing is not playback.
- lightedman 7y agoYou're making assumptions without all of the information. WHEN YOU ARE PLAYING ALONG you need to have the timing right. That means if I set the orchestra off, hit play on my metronome, and my beat is half a measure off, we just screwed up, especially when we're doing things like musically-timed parts of the on-stage performance. Or when I hit play on our Silent Movie with original orchestral score made by local musicians nights. Timing goes off, everything feels wrong. You'd need to be an actual performer to understand this, I suspect.
- TylerE 7y agoI'm not making any assumptions. You're the one who keeps bringing "playing along" and "timing" into it. That's not what this is about...at all.
- lightedman 7y agoYou said 20ms of latency is fine for media playback. In my actual use case, IT IS NOT. I'm playing ALONG with that music. And that music is piped into the SAME SET OF HEADPHONES as my guitar is also run into the computer. The latency of what I will hear music-wise, try to time along to, play, and then hear my guitar played back to me, would be roughly 40 or 50ms because of the additional input lags. Absolutely unacceptable to any serious musician. Add another 150ms or so if you're trying to hear your guitar by simply selecting the garbage "Listen to this device" option in the Windows Sound Mixer of any vintage after XP, as opposed to trying to listen to your guitar and time it with everything by unmuting in your sound card drivers for practically zero latency (if they even offer that option. It seems to be getting rarer and this was bog-standard on regular onboard audio back in the day.) I've already tried this with Bluetooth before. This is why I already know about this in such depth, and have a mixer board hooked up to my computer, where everything is hard-wired and pretty much latency-free. Bluetooth simply isn't there, and likely will not be any time soon.