2 ms·
> There are many reasons for players to have unions, and none of them apply to software developers. There are analogs to some of the things you listed. For ex
by criddell 7y ago
> There are many reasons for players to have unions, and none of them apply to software developers.
There are analogs to some of the things you listed.
For example, exclusivity contracts sounds a lot like non-compete agreements.
You play for them, or you don't play at all sound like employment agreements where the employer demands rights to everything you create during your time of employment.
You move your family to whatever shitty city bought your rights sounds a lot like being transferred to some place you don't want to go.
- Aperocky 7y agoI think your analogs are superficial. An NBA player have exactly one employer (the NBA) to work for. I have far greater mobility career wise. Nothing beats this difference.
- noirbot 7y agoThey're analogs in only the most surface way though. There's no "Computer Science Draft" where companies get to pick you and lock you into a contract that you must accept no matter which company it is. Sure, things like non-competes and inventions clauses are restrictive, but not even within the ballpark of the restrictions on most sports contracts. Most leagues make it literally impossible for you to "change jobs" to a different team AT ALL for years at a time, while at the same time reserving the right for them to transfer you to any other job they want. Sure, Google or whoever might try to transfer you to a different office, but you have the option to quit and try to find another job in the same city. Most athletes, if they're being traded from LA to Boston can either A. Move as commanded or B. Retire completely forever unless they move to another country. Being forced to quit and find a new job in the same industry sucks, but it's better than forced retirement...
- topkai22 7y agoNot really- non-compete agreements are very hard to enforce in many jurisdictions, and even where enforceable are limited in scope- you might be able to go from working on a check clearing system at one company to another company working on a check clearing system, but going from working on a check clearing system to working on software for medical equipment is going to be OK. Also, unions may not necessarily be interested in ending non-compete- they have a vested interest on keeping union employees within union employers. Your other two examples are completely different- while your statements are true for a single given employer, there are plenty of other employers out there willing to pay a roughly comparable wage. If you want to a side gig and your current employer won't allow it, you can start submitting resumes. If you don't want to transfer, you can start applying to other companies in your current location, or go for remote work. There is no equivalent in sport- US Professional sport leagues have a monopoly exemption approved by congress.