3 ms·
There's an MC Frontalot song called "Secrets from the Future" and the refrain is "You can't hide secrets from the future." It's something of a useful mantra to
by WorldMaker 7y ago
There's an MC Frontalot song called "Secrets from the Future" and the refrain is "You can't hide secrets from the future." It's something of a useful mantra to remind oneself that if "the future" is a part of your threat model, yes your encryption likely isn't enough because on a long enough timescale it is likely "the future" will crack it.
As with any other security issue, the question is "what is your threat model?" You can still justify encrypting your backup today if your threat model includes today's actors, however much you worry about "the future".
> 10 years from now, it might be as good as plain text.
Or 10 years from now it might be the next Linear A tablets to confuse cryptoarcheologists, unreadable and untranslatable and entirely foreign. If "the future" is in your threat model, don't forget the other fun forms of entropy beyond encryption being cracked such as encodings changing, file formats falling out of service/compatibility, "common knowledge" about slang or memes lost to the ages leaving things indecipherable, and so on and so forth. Most of those things are probably unlikely on only a 10 year time horizon, but you never can tell with "the future".
- SheepSlapper 7y ago"You can’t hide secrets from the future with math. You can try, but I bet that in the future they laugh at the half-assed schemes and algorithms amassed to enforce cryptographs in the past." Didn't expect to see Front on HN today, what a pleasant surprise.
- b4n4n4p4nd4 7y agocoughcaesarciphercough
- toppy 7y agoThis biblical prophecy from Luke 12,3 is solo true: " What you have said in the dark will be heard in the daylight, and what you have whispered in the ear in the inner rooms will be proclaimed from the roofs."
- shrimpx 7y agoI wonder what the intended meaning is. I presume it has to do with a presumed eventual urge to confess.
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoIn context, it appears to be saying "you can't keep secrets from God."
- shrimpx 7y agoOk but it implies/states that the secrets will be broadly divulged.
- toyg 7y agoIt’s basically “don’t try to get fresh with God”. Which conveniently translates into a call to humility and honesty towards its earthly representatives.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- CobrastanJorji 7y agoThe point about archeologists is a good one because it speaks to motive. In general, we should be very supportive of the efforts of distant historians who want to understand what humanity used to be like. We should not WANT to hide secrets from a sufficiently far future. I can't think of any secret that deserves to be hidden from them for any reason besides perhaps modesty.
- jessant 7y agoWhat is considered sufficiently far future may change with life extension technology.
- WorldMaker 7y agoRelatedly, that is a part of why I love the term "cryptoarcheology" in general, as a reminder that digital spaces will need archeologists too. There's it's somewhat shortened form "cryptarch", generally more used as a title ("cryptoarcheologist"), which was used in places in the Quantum Thief trilogy of books and is most probably already burned into your brain if you have played any of the Destiny series of videogames (and I presume was heavily influenced by Quantum Thief).
- moyix 7y agoHmm, I thought cryptarch was just crypt + arch with the arch part meaning “leader” (i.e. this sense https://www.etymonline.com/word/arch- https://www.etymonline.com/word/arch-), not archaeologist. Is there something about this in the Quantum Thief trilogy I’ve forgotten?
- xapata 7y ago> Or 10 years from now it might be the next Linear A tablets At some point in the future, after the universe has expanded to the extent that other galaxies are moving away from ours faster than the speed of light, someone might read our astronomy papers and wonder whether they can believe something that cannot be verified.
- tambourine_man 7y agoI always think of this as well. But it may not be so: https://phys.org/news/2020-01-evidence-key-assumption-discovery-dark.html https://phys.org/news/2020-01-evidence-key-assumption-discov...
- MaxBarraclough 7y ago> You can't hide secrets from the future With the usual disclaimer about one-time pads. > other fun forms of entropy beyond encryption being cracked such as encodings changing, file formats falling out of service/compatibility, "common knowledge" about slang or memes lost to the ages leaving things indecipherable I wonder what the digital archaeologists of the future will make of today's programming languages. (I was going to point out how far we've come since the languages of yesteryear, but we still have such horror-shows as Perl and Bash.)