4 ms·
I think their idea of a "startup" is different than mine. I'm not aware of cleantech or pharma companies being started by a couple of people in a bedroom or acr
by rhizome 16y ago
I think their idea of a "startup" is different than mine. I'm not aware of cleantech or pharma companies being started by a couple of people in a bedroom or across the internet, and though new companies have to be started somehow, it strikes me as hyperbole to compare Astia and YC.
- wzdd 16y agoI think you're right. From the article, as one of the reasons YC is unsuitable for women: > "Vivek Wadhwa has done research to show that the average entrepreneur is 35 and has 1.2 children. I don’t know many adults with children that will relocate to an incubator with the Y Combinator model. Society doesn’t support that yet, so that women can up and move for three months." I get the feeling that the average YC founder is a little younger than this. Oddly, so does the article: > [YC is] pretty much a den of 22-year-old guys who dropped out of Stanford with dreams of becoming the next Mark Zuckerberg Given that the article apparently contradicts itself internally, it's difficult to discover what exactly is anti-women about the YC model.
- simonw 16y agoFrom http://ycombinator.com/faq.html http://ycombinator.com/faq.html the average age of a YC Founder is 26. I wouldn't be surprised if that age has gone up a bit since the FAQ was written, certainly the Winter 2011 class feels like there's a healthy range of ages.
- mikeryan 16y agoI think your idea of a startup is very narrow. Tesla Motors was a startup. Talk to most VC's and you'll find they invest a ton of money into these types of companies. BTW most cleantech or pharma companies start as two engineering or science PHD students in lab somewhere, and these days those labs can be on different sides of the world.
- rhizome 16y agoKind of, but I think we actually agree. "Startup" may just be too vague a word to use for all of these kinds of companies, but I do think it's hyperbole to equate capital-intensive startups, like pharm or auto, with bootstrap operations that make videos easier to email or whatever.
- bhousel 16y agoYou've touched on an important point, and it's related to a fund's investment profile. Every fund has one, and Astia's and YC's profiles are very different. It's not really fair to make apples-to-apples comparisons between two funds with different profiles. YCombinator largely funds "toy apps". I mean that not in a bad way, but in a "the next big thing always starts out looking like a toy" kind of way. Every successful fund is managed by partners who make very conscious decisions about the kind of companies they will fund and the kinds of returns they might expect to get - YC is no exception.