3 ms·
This reminds me of my recent quest for an affordable after-market ECU. I really expected to find a bustling open source community of DIY ECU units with the adve
by ehnto 7y ago
This reminds me of my recent quest for an affordable after-market ECU. I really expected to find a bustling open source community of DIY ECU units with the advent of affordable micro-boards. But I think the work required and real risk of damage to expensive property might keep the barrier to entry high enough that it's yet to happen.
- schwap 7y agoHave you come across MegaSquirt[1]? The most recent iterations are neither inexpensive nor DIY but the earlier versions are still made as well. [1] http://www.msextra.com/product-range/traditional-megasquirt/ http://www.msextra.com/product-range/traditional-megasquirt/
- dwater 7y agoThe Speeduino project is similar but more DIY focused, and newer, and open source. https://speeduino.com/wiki/index.php/Speeduino https://speeduino.com/wiki/index.php/Speeduino
- ehnto 7y agoThose look pretty good, I'll have to dig in a bit deeper! At first glance, it looks like it might be a bit of a run around getting one to work with MAF and CAS sensors, but pretty much every other ECU wants a MAP sensor anyway so it wouldn't be a bad time to switch. I had heard of them but I thought they were a Miata specific ECU replacement not a general purpose one.
- olyjohn 7y agoI think that a lot of it it also due to the fact that the existing modern ECUs in most cars can just be reprogrammed in place. Why swap out the ECU, when you can just plug in to the OBD-II port and tune it? The use scope for replacement ECUs is pretty limited. Limited to a handful of 80s and 80s cars with extremely primitive ECUs (by today's standards), old cars that are being retrofitted to run fuel injection, and specialty one-off builds (where even most of these people buy something like a Motec, AEM, Holley, etc, etc ECU that plugs in and goes). The possibility of damage is the same whether or not the ECU is DIY or not. It's all in the tune whether you will blow up your engine or not.
- ehnto 7y ago> I think that a lot of it it also due to the fact that the existing modern ECUs in most cars can just be reprogrammed in place. I think you're right. In fact the only reason I'm digging into this is because I have one of very few 90s Nissan ECUs that hasn't been piggy backed (R33 S2 RB25DET). Because all others have a piggy back board available and aftermarket standalones are so common here, no one does flashing for that ECU either. You can use an R32 RB25DET ECU and piggy back that, but they are scarce here now and too expensive. > The possibility of damage is the same whether or not the ECU is DIY or not. It's all in the tune whether you will blow up your engine or not. I more meant from failure of the board or the code. You can be relatively confident with a modern commercial board, but I am worried about board failure on the street with DIY boards. If this were a track only car I wouldn't be as bothered, but it will be a street/track day car.