11 ms·
I read all of this as "Major union seeks to extract rent from an additional sector". I agree that putting developers on death marches is antithetical to everyt
by bob1029 7y ago
I read all of this as "Major union seeks to extract rent from an additional sector".
I agree that putting developers on death marches is antithetical to everything that is human, but it's not like you don't have options in this industry... Tech work isn't like coal mining where your health is legitimately at risk on a daily basis, and where the number of alternative options available to the average worker is low to non-existent.
Just yesterday we were all ogling over the salaries offered to engineers by the various top dogs in the valley. Anyone who works in tech on one of these salaries, and then turns around to complain about their collective rights... It all just feels incredibly childish to me.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- claudeganon 7y agoCollective rights extend beyond salary to the ability to have say over the basic terms and content of one’s labor. Some people can certainly be bought out of these concerns with high enough pay, but salaries at Google weren’t high enough to prevent people from organizing around sexual violence in the workplace nor work on Chinese surveillance. And I don’t think their organizing around these issues was “childish” in any fashion, no matter what they were being paid.
- me_me_me 7y ago> I agree that putting developers on death marches is antithetical to everything that is human You agree that this things are happening and its not OK. why do you follow that up with: > but it's not like you don't have options in this industry... Clearly if people are being taken advantage of its an issue. And its issue for large enough percentage of workforce for us to talk about it. Also this is global problem and salaries in game dev do not compare to SV. Well nothing compares to SV pay.
- quest88 7y agoI think op is saying that the video game developers are choosing to subject themselves to it and therefore they don't need protections. Even though conditions are said to be bad studios somehow seem to have an endless supply of developers.
- mlillie 7y agoThey do subject themselves to it. However, what that analysis lack is an understanding that the worker/employer power relationship is completely asymmetrical. Workers have everything to lose, Employers have nothing to lose. That leads to 'illogical' decisions such as workers who could find work elsewhere opting not to: Shit, their rent, their medicine, their family is on the line here. Maybe the new job will be worse, or have worse benefits, or not let you skip out early on Friday to go to soccer practice?
- ThrowawayR2 7y ago> "Employers have nothing to lose." Wrong in general and doubly wrong in the games industry where small game studios go bankrupt pretty much every other week. Not everybody is a FAANG or a billion dollar game publisher swimming in cash.
- TimothyBJacobs 7y agoAre not some of the worst abuses at AAA studios?
- Angostura 7y agoAs do coal miners.
- hinkley 7y agoAnd soldiers. You'll hear rumblings that both are a form of class warfare. I'm not trying to lump game developers into that class, but it makes me wonder what kind of 'happy accident' that is for influential people.
- commandlinefan 7y ago> it's not like you don't have options There's a catch-22 there, though - the more times you exercise your option (to move to a different job), the harder it is to exercise it the next time. Too many job changes is considered a negative.
- isthispermanent 7y agoEh, not at the moment. It's a sellers market. Maybe if a recession comes about.
- maxk42 7y agoIn other industries, perhaps, but it's standard in tech work to move jobs frequently. Every time I hire a new dev I slog through 200 - 300 resumes, the overwhelming majority of which have never held a job longer than 18 months.
- zebraflask 7y agoThere's an easy rule of thumb ... is there an upward trajectory in the responsibility or stature of the roles, or are the moves mostly lateral? A series of quick lateral moves - this obviously excludes freelancers and consultants who specialize in short term contracts - can be a sign of someone who stays just long enough to either show they're not great at the role and took off before they were let go, or otherwise has something else going on with them that you'd want to look into more. It could be perfectly understandable. It can often not be.
- the_watcher 7y agoThat definitely has not been the case in my observation, including my own job hopping career.
- embeddedpro 7y agoMaybe. But every time I've changed jobs my pay increased 20 or 30k. That means I'm doing higher demand work. So at least my most recent skills are extremely valuable.
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lazyasciiart 7y agoIf all engineers were making salaries like that, nobody would be ogling over them.
- reaperducer 7y agoI read all of this as "Major union seeks to extract rent from an additional sector". All the video game industry has to do is to give its workers better treatment than they would get under union stewardship. Problem solved. But I expect video games will follow the path of many other industries, and keep beating their mules until the mules revolt. It's a lesson that has played out publicly hundreds of times over the last few centuries, but new overlords always think they're better, smarter, luckier than those who came before them. They never are.
- L_Rahman 7y agoSadly they might actually be. It's game theoretically an efficient strategy because they can extract so much before the workers unionize that it'll still be cheaper than compensating them fairly all along.
- reaperducer 7y agoOnly if institutional myopia keeps them focused solely on the next quarter or two. The companies will learn that treating their employees fairly from the outset is cheaper than having a union force it upon them for the next 10 to 50 years.
- denkmoon 7y agoHow many micro-transaction laden titles can you shit out in 10 years? What is the half-life of a game publisher/studio executive?
- spamizbad 7y ago> All the video game industry has to do is to give its workers better treatment than they would get under union stewardship. Problem solved. Not even that. You could give employees half of what they would get under a union and you'd completely kill any motivation to unionize. The video game industry is so exploitative though that'll never happen.
- unapologetic 7y ago
- CalRobert 7y ago"not like you don't have options in this industry" Indeed, and whether or not one has options was painfully obvious at my last gig where the people in devops, backend systems design, etc. could walk into a new job in a day were pretty relaxed, but the people who lived and breathed Unity3D were crunching hard.
- unethical_ban 7y ago>and where the number of alternative options available to the average worker is low to non-existent. How many video game designers or programmers do you know? How bustling is that industry, in your opinion? Because I have a slightly different perspective from what I hear. Also, amount of money made != can't complain about their work or their conditions. Also, FAANG != EA, Activision, etc.
- themagician 7y agoMost people lie about their compensation though. The average tech worker salary isn’t $300k like HN wants to believe. The reality is that this board is mostly made up of the outliers. For every person getting $150k in stock options and “feels like that’s on the low end because everyone they know gets more” there are 10 others who get nothing.
- freehunter 7y agoThe reality is this board heavily trends towards SV and other tech hubs where salaries are outrageous and everyone is flush with choices for employers. Not everyone working in tech can walk into their local coffee shop and walk out with a job. For the millions of tech workers who don't live in Seattle or Austin or the Bay Area, salaries are under $100k and your city only has a small handful of companies you can choose from. Good luck if they're not hiring at the exact moment you're looking for a new job.
- VRay 7y agoClick the "Who's Hiring?" threads on this site. There are tons of 100% remote jobs with great benefits that pay 150k a year or more 150k in the Midwest won't let you save as much per year (in a combination of savings and home equity) as 300k in Silicon Valley, but it's pretty close That said, I'd be for a strong code monkeys union even though it'd probably screw me personally. The system we have is great for people who know their own worth and can advocate for themselves, but most people just aren't like that
- growlist 7y ago> Just yesterday we were all ogling over the salaries offered to engineers by the various top dogs in the valley. Anyone who works in tech on one of these salaries, and then turns around to complain about their collective rights... It all just feels incredibly childish to me. Also, the concern over all the requisite 'woke' issues incongruously combined with hoarding enough filthy lucre to have FU money by 35 is amusing - a person like this might be described as a 'Champagne socialist' in the UK.
- tclancy 7y ago>Just yesterday we were all ogling over the salaries offered to engineers by the various top dogs in the valley Which of those companies were video game makers?
- Tiktaalik 7y ago> but it's not like you don't have options in this industry... The games industry over the last decade has been experiencing an incredible amount of consolidation so options have been if anything narrowing, as more and more game development jobs rely on working for Big Corp Publishers. Game development is a unique ecosystem of tech. Sure programmers can pivot to working at Facebook or whatever, but lets be honest that the work and technology used is wildly different, and there's friction to that change. Also worth noting that there's more to coders in games. What about the artists, producers, qa and other workers?
- midnightclubbed 7y ago> Also worth noting that there's more to coders in games. What about the artists, producers, qa and other workers? Thank you for pointing this out. Even within the dev-team side of game production (leaving out legal, marketing, sales, operations etc) the coders are typically 1/3 or less of the team size. Programmers can pivot (with varying amounts of friction) in to other areas of tech. For the designers, testers, producers and artists there are fewer options to use their skills outside of games.
- GoodJokes 7y agolol rent from another sector, you mean extracting rent from capitalists? That is just called wealth redistribution. Sure, tech workers might be generally more well off, but we all are still being taken for a ride by executives, founders, shareholders, etc.
- mempko 7y agoStrange, actors, writer, and others in Hollywood are part of a union and they somehow get multi-million-dollar pay...
- uerobert 7y agoMost do not get multi-million-dollar pay, hell a lot of people there barely make a living. The reason there is an union there is because a lot of those same people would work for free to get a chance at making it in the industry (interns don't get paid), that is highly exploitable.
- jakelazaroff 7y agoLet's use Facebook as an example. The median employee salary is $240,000 [1], but Facebook makes an average of $1,620,000 in revenue per employee [2]. Why is it okay for a company to extract a so much more money from an employee than they pay them, but not okay for employees to band together to get paid what they're worth? [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/facebook-median-pay-240000-2017-2018-4/ https://www.businessinsider.com/facebook-median-pay-240000-2... [2] https://www.businessinsider.com/tech-companies-revenue-employee-2017-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/tech-companies-revenue-emplo...
- fennecfoxen 7y agoThis is the wrong number. The average revenue per employee isn't what determines a wage, even when the employees are fully interchangeable: it's the marginal revenue brought in by each extra employee.
- sailfast 7y agoI’d go further and say “marginal net revenue” rather than the gross. Using a revenue number for this makes no sense. Let’s ignore for now that this revenue also owes a great deal to the commons that is never paid back by most companies.
- quotemstr 7y agoOne of the persistent sources of economic misunderstanding is the difficulty of marginal thinking. It's frequently counterintuitive and leads to a false sense of injustice, e.g., "If teachers are so important, why are they paid so little?"
- omarchowdhury 7y ago> but not okay for employees to band together to get paid what they're worth? Does not Facebook also retain the right to hire employees willing to take less?
- unapologetic 7y ago
- tsimionescu 7y agoUnions are not just there to protect people close to poverty wages or who work in potentially deadly conditions. Sure, as a software engineer you are pretty well off to begin with, but there is also the question of fairness - how much of the company's success are workers actually reaping? Are they really getting a fair share of the fruits of their labor? The union should help with that, if nothing else.
- unapologetic 7y ago> Tech work isn't like coal mining where your health is legitimately at risk on a daily basis The way the game industry drives people is absolutely devastating to your health. > Anyone who works in tech on one of these salaries, and then turns around to complain about their collective rights... It all just feels incredibly childish to me. I mean, if we want to start insulting people for having really dumb opinions we can go that route. Personally I don't think people who want to fight for their standard of living are being "childish".
- theFeller00 7y agoI don't feel like I have any options. I've felt burned out for about four years now. Our tech stack is very old and my my interest in programming is near zero at this point. I feel like I'm just waiting out the inevitable. I don't live in SV or an area with more than a handful of companies who would provide a desirable job.
- brozaman 7y agoNone of these issues can be solved by an union. Union won't make your job interesting, and won't make you like your job again. It certainly won't help with any of the issues you describe.
- DaniloDias 7y ago>> but it's not like you don't have options in this industry... Tech work isn't like coal mining where your health is legitimately at risk on a daily basis, and where the number of alternative options available to the average worker is low to non-existent >> Anyone who works in tech on one of these salaries, and then turns around to complain about their collective rights... I worked in the gaming industry and left. I’ve mentored several folks who made similar transitions. Consequently, I have perspective based on those experiences. I think it’s a fundamental mistake to think that transitioning from the gaming industry into general tech is an easy transition. Most people in the gaming industry have a severe form of professional PTSD due to the expectations around death march development. They have strived for a career in gaming where employers see plenty of potential hires and can pay them less as a result. These people end up with limited financial cushions, burnout and depression. They end up believing their only options are to pick up and move to another gaming shop for shit money and the same working conditions. Stay in this “career” long enough, and you are almost guaranteed health complications related to obesity and drug abuse. Yeah, it ain’t glamorous to stay in gaming, but experience means they’ll be an easy hire at the next company and they’ll be able to continue covering the mortgage. I am mostly anti-union, but I believe unions are actually necessary in the gaming industry. It is pretty shitty and deserves to feel the pain they’ve been inflicting in their developers, PMs, producers and testers. The gaming industry should not be seen as a career destination if you aren’t in finance/marketing. It should be a stepping stone in a bigger career, but an extremely short one so devs can learn EVERYTHING THAT YOU SHOULD NOT DO IN PROGRAM MANAGEMENT, EMPLOYEE RELATIONS AND SELF-CARE.
- gwbas1c 7y ago> Tech work isn't like coal mining where ... the number of alternative options available to the average worker is low to non-existent. Strange, I tend to see situations where some people can pick up a new job at the drop of a hat, and others just struggle to stay employed. The industry goes through cycles, and someone who has a certain kind of engineering talent can easily pick up and move to another job. Everyone else is often stuck taking what they can get.
- zemo 7y ago> it's not like you don't have options in this industry... have you ever worked in video games?
- vkou 7y agoIf you call the formation of a union rent-extraction, what do you call the infliction of unpaid overtime on employees?
- CydeWeys 7y agoYour comment is really rubbing me the wrong way. How is it "childish" to band together and fight for better working conditions? Because you aren't literally dying in mines you have no right to demand improvements? Your bar is that low?
- Can_Not 7y agoThat commenter committed fallacy of relative privation.
- hinkley 7y ago> Tech work isn't like coal mining where your health is legitimately at risk on a daily basis You sure about that? No, a coal vein isn't going to fall on our heads and the factory isn't going to burn down with the doors locked. We still don't understand inflammation and stress, but it's not looking good right now, and death marches put you into both.
- SSSDFRO 7y agoI read this as, “More computer science jobs to be shipped overseas”