3 ms·
Sorry in advance, this is a bit of a rant... The problem is not defined benefit vs defined contribution really, it's that companies are not really required to
by LatteLazy 7y ago
Sorry in advance, this is a bit of a rant...
The problem is not defined benefit vs defined contribution really, it's that companies are not really required to fund defined benefit.
There are 1001 third party companies (normally insurers) who will happily underwrite a defined benefit scheme (so if the employer goes under the pensions are fine). But that would mean employers actually making pensions contributions that would actually fund the actual cost. Firms prefer to under pay the schemes. Depending on the scheme/firm/local-laws, that might be by just underpaying it, or by more cunning means like using the funds to buy company stock (so it looks like its funded on paper but you're just as screwed when the employer fails, Ironically this is what the federal government is doing with social security too) or by making optimistic assumptions (if I assume all workers die a week after retirement age and a 9% interest rate, final salary pensions need only cost me 5cents a head today! Can you prove I'm wrong?)
Unions (where they exist and have influence) also don't want to push this. Admitting the employer is unlikely to pay is a serious accusation that won't be proven for 20+ years. If you press hard and the employer DOES up their (real) contributions then that means you'll lose out somewhere else in the compensation package (so less health coverage or lower raises). Plus, If you get someone 1000 dollars more in 20 years, but 10 dollars less now, they won't thank you,they'll demand to know where there 10 dollars is!
This is also the reason politicians won't regulate harder: it would push firms to declare bankruptcy sooner (and the electorate punishes that, better let the problem worsen and hope its the next guys issue) and it would mean many firms withdrawing or cutting back their schemes. And again, people would rather have the promise of a good pension (that will likely never happen) than the certainty of a mediocre pension.
The key issue here is a mix of costs and people being strongly incentivised to lie about a cost now as the problem won't happen for decades.
The only advantage defined contribution has is that it is harder to cheat. But actually, defined benefit schemes are less risky and far more appropriate for the average dummy than defined contribution schemes.
- scandox 7y ago> But actually, defined benefit schemes are less risky and far more appropriate for the average dummy than defined contribution schemes. Well, yeah because defined benefit actually makes some kind of commitment on what you're going to get, whereas defined contribution just tells you what you'll give, right? I mean it's all in the name. DC is just "give us yer money and sure we'll do our best for you, as long as our fees are paid"....
- ghaff 7y agoWell, it's more than that. With defined contribution you can invest in a reasonably diversified pool of assets and, while there are no guarantees, you will most likely come out OK over a long period of time. The bigger problem is that unsophisticated investors may overly invest in risky assets that don't pan out or they don't invest at all/borrow against savings/etc.
- scandox 7y agoOk. But even with a sensible investment strategy a major economic decline close to your retirement can result in you getting a lot less than you expected, right? It just seems to me a pension should principally offer a reasonable level of certainty (to those that choose to have it).
- ghaff 7y agoThe thing is that pensions aren't magic money trees. They're invested in the market just like anything else. So if there's a major economic decline close to your retirement, they may well become insolvent. Maybe they'll be bailed out (with basically other people's money) or maybe they won't be. (Pensions also don't really protect you if inflation spikes.) Individual investors do have the option of investing in things like treasuries and annuities. Of course, in an economic collapse, all bets are off. But if you're willing to put up with low returns (maybe 3%), you can invest your money pretty safely.
- dredmorbius 7y agoDB pensions spread their risk and return over multiple cohorts. DC retirement plans heap all correlated market risk on individual retirees. Given that the risks of an underfunding are greater than an overfunding, that market returns are exogenous to the merits of any given retiree, and the goal is to supply adequate income to live on in retirement, the arguments in favour of a DB plan, a payment mandate by the employer, a government backing, and severe penalties for malfeasance, including clawbacks to investors and creditors of deadbeat employers, seems more than appropriate.
- eldavido 7y agoI take the status quo as my starting point. McClatchy just had pension trouble. So does my home state of Illinois. So does this company, apparently. You seem to think it's possible to just magic a large-scale change in human behavior into existence. It isn't. I think DC+social security is a pretty fair compromise. You're never going to starve if you totally screw up. There's also Medicare to help pay medical expenses. So the worst-case scenario isn't awful. On the other hand, if you want a comfortable retirement with a nice house, travel, etc., you need to be a good steward of a DC plan. I also think having people with a little more skin in the game (the stock market) will help to tamp down this tiresome class politics about how the 1% is screwing everyone over. Pensions are big investors, it's not fair that some investors (pensioners) get bailed out in a bad market environment, whereas others (DC plan participants) don't. Don't forget, pensions don't magically create money, they have to invest and rely on the whims of the market just like DC plan participants. Plus, there are good DC plans. The better ones opt you into a target date retirement fund and automatically invest in a reasonable basket of securities so you don't have to figure it out yourself. Human Interest is a great example of a simple, no-frills plan I've seen. My wife's Schwab account is too complicated. I get that DB might be better in theory but I fail to see how, given the constraints of reality, and human nature, and politics, we aren't going to get a repeat of the current DB fiasco over and over again. Just look at the incentives.
- ghaff 7y agoThe other issue is that DB was historically oriented towards lifetime or at least long-term employment at GM, federal/state government, etc. It doesn't have to be that way. I suppose you could have some sort of common pool that employers paid into. You're still creating what's basically a large organization-specific retirement scheme. But if you somehow extend it more broadly, it starts to look a lot like another version of Social Security--which probably doesn't make a lot of sense. I like the fact that I have a DB plan from a prior employer but, as you say, I'm not sure it's a great fit for most situations moving forward.
- LatteLazy 7y agoI strongly agree about the "mix of the two". Though social security is just a defined benefit scheme that's bankrupt and replying on a political bailout so I'm not sure I'd include it. The big issue here though is how to make either work for the average person? A defined benefit scheme where the employer is fiddling the books will fail. A defined contribution scheme where the management company is charging fat fees and pushing risky investments will fail. Can we really trust the majority of people with no financial acumen to tell the difference? I feel like both require the user to swim with sharks right now...