4 ms·
I keep reading weird stuff from the US about employee pension obligations being a burden on companies, and those savings getting eaten or stolen in all sorts of
by mcv 7y ago
I keep reading weird stuff from the US about employee pension obligations being a burden on companies, and those savings getting eaten or stolen in all sorts of corporate shenanigans. Are these things really not handled by life insurance companies and subject to all sorts of regulation? That sounds woefully irresponsible.
- ldoughty 7y agoMost of the time it's seen by management as an expense with no positive business value (they pay out to people that are no longer useful to the company)... Therefore it's a major target for elimination if possible. Bankruptcy is a great way to do this. If you remember that the "best" leaders from a stock investor (or greedy owner) perspective are psychopaths (lack empathy), and these people actually look really great on paper (lower costs, no/little immediate impact on profits), it's not surprising.
- mcv 7y agoThat's exactly why it shouldn't even be on the company's budget. They should pay for it to an insurance company while the employee works there, and once the employee doesn't, the insurance takes care of it. Take the employer out of the equation once they're no longer relevant.
- asdf21 7y ago>Take the employer out of the equation once they're no longer relevant. Not exactly, if the company is willing to go so far as bankruptcy / reincorporation... how will any previous contracts with whatever insurance company last through that?
- Retric 7y agoThe idea is an employee’s pension must be fully funded before they leave and then handled by a 3rd party. At that point the company could dissolve without impacting retired workers.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- philwelch 7y agoYes, that's how 401(k)s work and why most employers have switched to them.
- Retric 7y agoI am specifically referring to pensions. It’s true that 401(k)s also have this feature, however many employees prefer the defined benefit a pension provides over managing their own returns and the temptations associated with managing money. The core issue is really poor US regulation over any specific issue with pensions. PS: The swap to 401k’s in the US is mostly about cost savings. Companies can simply reduce their contributions without much if any backlash. Meanwhile, third parties profit from managing 401k’s and therefore market them heavily.
- alistairSH 7y agoThe insurance company is effectively acting as a giant escrow account on behalf of the employees/retirees. The employer pays into the account at whatever rate is required to fully fund retirements. The insurance company manages those funds. If the employer goes bankrupt, the funds are not accessible by raiders/PE firms.
- eldavido 7y agoThis already exists. It's called a 401(k).
- thatfrenchguy 7y agoExcept 401(k)s are crazy underfunded: https://www.marketwatch.com/story/this-is-the-average-401k-savings-by-age-2019-01-31 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/this-is-the-average-401k-s... (look at the median)
- alistairSH 7y agoNot sure if serious.meme A defined benefit plan is (nominally) funded by the employer with little or no input from the employee at time of investment or distribution. A 401k is funded by the employee, with the employee managing contribution level, fund investment, and eventually distributions. They're only the same, if by same you mean "retirement plans". The details are substantially different.
- eldavido 7y agoA 401k is an account, funded by a mix of employer and employee contributions, that's beyond reach of bankruptcy. That part is the same. The only bit that's different is the self-management of assets, of which many companies are happy to do, increasingly for lower and lower fees. 0.2-0.3% being common which I bet goes toe-to-toe with good pension managers. They really aren't that different.
- alistairSH 7y ago
- rsynnott 7y agoThe way it works at least here generally is that the pension fund is held in trust, on a per employee basis, by an insurance company (usually) employed by the company to do that. So it's (in principle) immune to bankruptcy of both the employer and third party insurance company.
- epc 7y agoTraditional “defined benefit” employee pensions in the US were treated as a balance sheet line item. There wasn't a separate, fenced off, account where funds were secured. In the 1980s it became popular for “corporate raiders” (today’s “private equity”) to target companies with mediocre corporate results but well funded pensions. Because the pension obligations weren't sequestered, you could legitimately take over a company, pay yourself a dividend using the pension fund, strip the company of assets and then run it into the ground. Through it all, the MBAs, the corporate raiders, the bankers would say (and still say) they're just improving the efficiency of these companies.
- saiya-jin 7y agoIs this still true for majority of the US working force? As an European I find it ridiculous that your pension could be wiped out like that, and not be completely separated from employer either managed by state, or dedicated pension fund manager (what I prefer but citizens have no say in this, you have to move state to change this). Companies go bankrupt all the times, small or big. If it gets wiped out, what happens to those people? Getting by on social help, food stamps and super basic healthcare through rest of their lives?
- seanc 7y agoIn the worst case, yes. Most often as a creditor they get something like 20-50% of their pension. Then people often are forced to sell their house. It's devastating to be sure. And "super basic healthcare" might actually be overstating the case.
- Bartweiss 7y agoDoes this not happen in Europe also? It's rare for US employees to lose everything, but fairly common for pensions to be reduced to <50% of their promised level. And I thought I'd heard about similar cases by European companies, like Maersk attempting to slash pension payouts even without going bankrupt. (Although I just looked, and apparently Maersk's move was specific to a UK division; perhaps this is another case where UK law sits halfway between the US and Europe? https://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/personalfinance/2831055/Maersk-move-alarms-pensions-watchdog.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/personalfinance/2831055/...)
- sct202 7y agoThere are regulations and insurance policies for pensions (PBGC), but they still operate independently and can do very badly if the projections of the costs that were made in 1980s when all these people were promised benefits never grew fast enough or had a few bad investments. The PBGC also only insures a limited portion of the promised benefit, so pensioners benefits usually will get cut either to prevent the fund from failing or it will get cut if it fails and gets taken over by the PBGC.
- linuxftw 7y agoYou should look into the GM/UAW worker bailouts. It's total corruption, top to bottom. Basically, the UAW 'invested' in GM unsecured debt. GM files for bankruptcy, those bonds become worthless. With no authority whatsoever to do so, the US government gave those bonds seniority in the bankruptcy, nationalized GM, and left senior creditors holding the bag. All of this was completely unprecedented and way outside of what the law allows. There wasn't a lot of mainstream coverage of all this, you had to dig for smaller journalists to find what was actually happening. But anyway, that's the name of the game. Take on a lot of debt, stuff that debt into your pension, go bankrupt, company is restructured without pension debt. There is also the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation, so this corporate debt is shift to the tax payer. It's corruption that knows no bounds in the USA. Both major political parties are guilty, we have to dismantle the federal monster, it's the only way forward.