8 ms·
There's lots of evidence milk isn't as good for you as the dairy industry advertises.
by m463 7y ago
There's lots of evidence milk isn't as good for you as the dairy industry advertises.
- jononomo 7y agoWhere did you get that idea? Milk is one of the 2-3 most nutritious foods on Earth. In fact, milk has been designed by evolution over millions of years to be precisely what a mammal needs to thrive.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoSome humans have the necessary genes to digest milk, some do not. Can't lump all mammals together. > Milk contains a type of sugar called lactose, which is distinct from the sugars found in fruit and other sweet foods. When we are babies, our bodies make a special enzyme called lactase that allows us to digest the lactose in our mother’s milk. But after we are weaned in early childhood, for many people this stops. Without lactase, we cannot properly digest the lactose in milk. As a result, if an adult drinks a lot of milk they may experience flatulence, painful cramps and even diarrhoea. (It’s worth noting that in other mammals, there aren’t any lactase-persistent adults – adult cows don’t have active lactase, and neither do cats or dogs, for example). https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20190218-when-did-humans-start-drinking-cows-milk https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20190218-when-did-humans-...
- soperj 7y agoThen how do cats digest it?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- InvaderFizz 7y agoPoorly. Adult cats are generally lactose intolerant[0]. 0: https://www.prestigeanimalhospital.com/services/cats/blog/why-cats-and-cows-milk-dont-mix https://www.prestigeanimalhospital.com/services/cats/blog/wh...
- xnyan 7y agoCats drinking bowls of milk is a TV thing or people who don't know better. Almost all mammals, including humans, lose the ability to effectively process lactose at some point in their life. Keeping the ability to process lactose as an adult is somewhat unique to humans and even then most will stop producing lactase before they die.
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoIs there a test to determine if you do make lactase?
- toomuchtodo 7y agohttps://www.healthline.com/health/lactose-tolerance-tests#test-types https://www.healthline.com/health/lactose-tolerance-tests#te...
- xnyan 7y agoRapidly after drinking a glass of milk (or any of the many, many things that include lactose) it becomes very very clear that I am lactose intolerant to both myself and everyone around me.
- mcv 7y ago> "Some humans have the necessary genes to digest milk, some do not. Can't lump all mammals together." Note, adult mammals. Drinking milk as a baby is literally the definition of mammal. Even the platypus, which lays eggs and lacks teats, counts as mammal because they still produce milk to feed their children.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> designed by evolution over millions of years to be precisely what a mammal needs to thrive Infant mammals. Adults consuming the milk of another species is recent. (About 10,000 years in humans.) We have mixed evidence for the benefits of milk. It was a rich source of calories when those were scarce. Today, it might promote obesity. And good advice for some is bad advice for others. For example, milk boosts iron at the expense of vitamin D; that makes it favorable for light-skinned people at high latitudes [1]. Milk's branding as a superfood essential for kids is a product of post-war propaganda [2]. (TL; DR The U.S. government boosted dairy demand to feed soldiers. After the war, that production was threatened. So civilian demand was boosted.) [1] https://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/131/1/e144 https://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/131/1/e144 [2] https://dairymarkets.org/pubPod/pubs/EB9505.pdf https://dairymarkets.org/pubPod/pubs/EB9505.pdf
- masonic 7y agoproduction was threatened. So civilian demand was boosted. That makes no sense. When production is "threatened", artificially boosting demand would be the exactly wrong thing to do.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> When production is "threatened", artificially boosting demand would be the exactly wrong thing to do There was wartime demand. Dairy farmers invested to meet it. War ends. Demand goes down. That capital must now be written off, re-purposed, or the demand re-started. We chose the last option. Production as in productive capital or productive potential.
- gsich 7y agoAnd also lots of evidence for the contrary.
- m463 7y agoThe contrary would be: "Milk is better for you than the dairy industry advertises". So show a dairy industry advertisement, and show that milk is actually better than THAT. :)
- Fricken 7y agoThere's evidence my ancestors have been drinking milk for at least 10,000 years. It's field tested.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> There's evidence my ancestors have been drinking milk for at least 10,000 years Most humans can't digest lactose after infancy [1]. For those who can, we have limited research around the quantity in and frequency with which their ancestors consumed whole milk. Comparisons to modern milk, produced by stressed-out cows bred for volume and fed god-knows-what, are tenuous. [1] https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/condition/lactose-intolerance https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/condition/lactose-intolerance
- Fricken 7y agoNutritional science has gotten a lot of things badly wrong, so it plays second fiddle to how I feel when I add or remove something from my diet. I've tried on a few occasions to cut dairy from my diet. It was sub-optimal.
- masonic 7y agoMost humans can't digest lactose after infancy [1]. That source: "Approximately 65 percent of the human population has a reduced ability to digest lactose after infancy." "Reduced ability" != "Can't"
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gsich 7y ago>Most humans can't digest lactose after infancy [1]. Here (Europe) most can. So it's normal to digest lactose here. In other words, yes percentage wise you are correct. But is's not equally distributed.
- fiblye 7y agoSome people die from being near peanut dust. That doesn't mean nuts are unhealthy to those who can eat them. Even those who are included in "lactose intolerant" populations actually have no trouble chugging a huge glass of milk everyday along with some cheese and yogurt. Intolerance charts like you'd find on Wikipedia would lead you to suggest east Asians can't consume milk at all without discomfort, yet yogurt for breakfast, milk during lunch, a milk tea before dinner and ice cream after isn't even the slightest bit uncommon and causes no trouble for most people. That some people can consume liters a day (or gallons, for those trying to gain muscle fast) seems to indicate that some people evolved to be fine with dairy.
- t0ddbonzalez 7y ago> " There's lots of evidence milk isn't as good for you as the dairy industry advertises." lol at this ridiculous comment. Present the evidence please. How many millions of years do you think mammals have been drinking milk for?
- uhtred 7y agoTheir mother's milk, during infancy. No mammals other than humans drink milk after infancy, and humans have only been doing that for a few thousand years. I'm sure there's links to evidence I can find but I'm not going to waste my time as it's common sense.
- melq 7y agoIf its healthy during infancy why would it be unhealthy during adulthood?
- bluGill 7y agoBecause for species other than humans the ability to digest milk is lost when they become an adult. This genetic adaptation changing everything.
- uhtred 7y agoBecause the average adult doesn't need such a high concentration of fat and calories in a single drink / bowl of cereal / piece of cheese etc. If it was healthy and natural you'd be drinking your mother's milk as an adult, but I'm sure you aren't.
- melq 7y ago>Because the average adult doesn’t need ... This doesn’t mean consuming a moderate amount of milk is somehow unhealthy.
- lm28469 7y agoHow many millions of years do you think _adult_ mammals have been drinking milk _coming from other mammals_ for?