7 ms·
> The world changes and sometimes it sucks but that is how progress is made. Progress for whom? Seems like a false dichotomy to me.
by heavyset_go 7y ago
> The world changes and sometimes it sucks but that is how progress is made.
Progress for whom? Seems like a false dichotomy to me.
- halbritt 7y agoI speculate that as corporations take over farming, their operations become more efficient providing greater yields per acre and for the amount of fuel consumed. If true, this is net positive for humanity as a whole as more people can get fed and there are less carbon emissions doing so. There is the problem that corporations tend to trend toward becoming sociopathic entities unless carefully managed, so it's not all win.
- mrpopo 7y ago> there are less carbon emissions doing so. Intensive farming as practiced by corporations today is among the worst culprits regarding carbon emissions. It is more profitable to practice intensive till-heavy farming since it takes advantage of the nutrients already stored in the soil. The disadvantage is its unsustainability. After few decades of soil-tilling, it becomes quite poor in nutrients, and will have reduced yield. Corporations can afford to destroy land and move on to the next one, until nothing is left. This is opposed to regenerative/conservative agriculture. https://www.drawdown.org/solutions/food/regenerative-agriculture https://www.drawdown.org/solutions/food/regenerative-agricul... https://www.drawdown.org/solutions/food/conservation-agriculture https://www.drawdown.org/solutions/food/conservation-agricul...
- halbritt 7y ago> Intensive farming as practiced by corporations today is among the worst culprits regarding carbon emissions. Relative to what? What are the CO2 emissions per bushel of grain for the practices you've described? My point about reduced carbon emissions is specific to corporate farms using modern equipment which is more precise, thanks to auto-guidance via GPS, more efficient, as a result of the diesel engines being more modern and also as a result of other technologies that allow the tractors to have larger implements, travel faster, and consume less horsepower and finally lower emissions as a result of being compliant with more recent emissions standards.
- 6510 7y agohttps://res.mdpi.com/d_attachment/sustainability/sustainability-10-03218/article_deploy/sustainability-10-03218.pdf https://res.mdpi.com/d_attachment/sustainability/sustainabil...
- halbritt 7y agoThis is fascinating, but also somewhat orthogonal to the argument, assuming there was nothing I missed when skimming that paper. The paper itself describes farming practices that are more sustainable, and possibly more efficient after introducing a new formula to measure efficiency. I'm not sufficiently well-informed to critically assess the formula given, although on the surface it seems fine. To clarify my original assertion, modern farming equipment with the latest technology as employed by corporate farms increase the efficiency of industrial farming methods vs. farming equipment being used that's 30-40 years old. There are a few common metrics that I use to base my assertion on, that is gallons of fuel used per cultivated acre, as well as yield per acre. From those, one can derive yield per gallon of fuel and subsequently carbon emissions as a result. I'm not suggesting that represents a lifecycle analysis of the entire crop, but I think it's still sufficient to evaluate the impact of modern equipment vs. aging equipment.
- 6510 7y agoFor the most part I just thought it was interesting. You asked in relation to what modern farming is among the worst culprits regarding carbon emissions. I suppose that merits a comparison to other know ways to grow food? Most of the crops "we" grow use to grow just fine on their own. We've cultivated them to be dependent. It doesn't seem unreasonable to think we can cut carbon emissions beyond 100% (eventually) To add a funny: We wont optimize the Nodejs to the point it changes into ERLANG. It takes a whole new approach.
- halbritt 7y agoI agree that the comparison deserves merit, but it's a lengthy discussion. I'd presented a simple dichotomy. > ...use to grow just fine on their own. We've cultivated them to be dependent. It doesn't seem unreasonable to think we can cut carbon emissions beyond 100% (eventually) There are a couple of constraints there. We have a limited amount of arable land to feed the world's population and a significant amount of the carbon emissions in modern farming practices comes from harvesting and transport. I can't see any way to harvest and transport agriculture products without carbon emissions today.
- knockout9461 7y agoI'm not sure whether or not corporate farming leads to less emissions, but the environmental impact should not be the only factor evaluated for whether or not corporate farming consolidation is good for humanity. What may be lost in efficiency is gained in good jobs for middle class people to make a living. If we're talking large scale change for the environment, why not electrify farm equipment, expand our solar and wind capacity to meet the demand, and allow for small farmers to still carve out a solid living and make the Heartland a place with thriving communities?
- halbritt 7y agoI'm not suggesting that corporate farming consolidation is good for humanity. I'm suggesting that there is a benefit to using modern farming equipment. Fundamentally, I believe that corporate farming consolidation is a risk to the global food supply. ADM is proof of how terrible that can be.
- dvfjsdhgfv 7y agoI share your sentiment. In the case of farming is not so much progress as regress, at least in many cases. For example, in Europe farmers can get the money from the EU, but only if they use certain seeds. So basically there are a couple of crops to choose from that get repeated year by year. What happens to the soil is a great disaseter. Obviusly nobody can use more natural kinds of fertilizers these days and the food gradually loses its nutrient value. The farmers are happy about announcing their bio certification but very few actually care about what happens to the soil. A similar "optimization" is being done with animal farming. It's disgusting and very far from actual progress.
- modo_mario 7y agoCan you clarify the money for use of certain seeds bit? I'm quite interested in EU affairs and hadn't heard of this. I'd expect something that wouldn't give money for certain seeds but this seems like that turned around.
- pjc50 7y agoYeah, EU farm subsidies are problematic but they're also notoriously mis-reported, so this needs proper citation.
- dvfjsdhgfv 7y agohttps://translate.google.com/translate?hl=&sl=pl&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.agrofakt.pl%2Fdoplaty-nasion-25-czerwca%2F https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=&sl=pl&tl=en&u=htt...
- dvfjsdhgfv 7y agoFrankly, I was very suprised to hear this, too. I visited a rural family last year and we had a short chat about this. I had expected the subsidies are for machines etc., but influencing the choice of crops in this way seems really misguided. Whoever created this had good intentions, but the results are lamentable. (The family in question still have a large portion of land they cultivate in a more natural way, alternating the crops properly etc.)
- tangue 7y agoWe should clarify the notion of progress. Technological advances are not necessarily progress. Progress imho is something that benefits the whole humanity without harming irremediably nature. But I have the impression that each one has its own definition.