3 ms·
Haha, called it! Feynman warned about this specific phenomenon: basing new physics on the points at the extreme end of your graph, where the measurements are l
by ncmncm 7y ago
Haha, called it!
Feynman warned about this specific phenomenon: basing new physics on the points at the extreme end of your graph, where the measurements are least reliable.
In this case, these points correspond to demolition of the most distant and youngest stars in the sample, which could differ in many ways from the common, much more recent events. Low metallicity is a difference that is obvious to every AP, but there is no reason to assume it is the only one. We just don't get to study any young-universe stars that haven't blown up.
Did anybody even discuss metallicity and possible effects on brightness of t1a sn's, when DE was first proclaimed? If not, why not?
- dmix 7y agoDoes this have any affect on the search for dark matter? Are the two interconnected at all?
- lanstin 7y agoNo. Dark matter is assumed to exist from the excessively quick rotation of stars around the cores of galaxies. Dark energy is/was assumed to exist in anomalous expansion of the universe based on redshifts.
- stan_rogers 7y ago>Dark matter is assumed to exist from the excessively quick rotation of stars around the cores of galaxies. That's what initiated Zwicky's notion in the '30s. It is far from being the only, or even the main, evidence for dark matter (which can be read as "mass effects we can detect not associated with matter we can currently detect").
- ncmncm 7y agoMore accurately: motion dynamics not compatible with both General Relativity and the mass we can see and reasonably infer. There is of course a stupendously huge amount of mostly invisible "interstellar medium", and even more "intergalactic medium", mostly ions of loose atoms and small molecules, and we use estimates of how much of that there must be. If its motion has anything to do with plasma fluid dynamics, all bets are off, because those equations are what mathematicians call intractable, and physicists would call career-limiting. They will happily declare 3x more unknowable Dark Matter than normal stuff before allowing plasma dynamics to have any effect on anything. Can hardly blame them.
- gameswithgo 7y agoThis finding would not cast any doubt on the existence of dark matter.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> Haha, called it! One or two years from now I invite you to take a look back at this comment and see if you still feel so smug. This is a relatively recent paper, give it some time to be chewed up and spit out by the cosmological community before hailing it as the deathknell of a decades old tricky problem.
- ncmncm 7y agoI will happily eat crow if they find reliable independent corroboration of the actual distance of these events. That will not be easy. The universe has many ways to adjust the relative brightness of photons at different wavelengths on a common path, and many ways to vary the relative brightness when they are emitted.