3 ms·
I think identification of what constitutes kid's content, or content predominantly viewed by people under the legal drinking age if 21, is really borked. To pr
by ineedasername 7y ago
I think identification of what constitutes kid's content, or content predominantly viewed by people under the legal drinking age if 21, is really borked.
To provide one example of many, my son (under 12) likes a channel Dope or Nope. It's sort of a quick drive-by review of a bunch of products that share a theme, but they are almost always toys, games, or gadgets that skew to a younger audience. And yet it's not uncommon for alcohol-based ads to appear. Which, just, no, not at all okay.
Do YouTubers have any control over this? Or is it purely in the domain of The Algorithm?
- jedberg 7y agoAnother excellent aspect of why YouTube needs humans to curate kids content. This never happens on network TV because there is always a human gatekeeper. YouTube needs to learn that you can't run your entire business on machine learning when it comes to kids. Machine learning is a tool, but they need to use it appropriately to enhance the humans, not replace them.
- alfalfasprout 7y ago...and your 12 year old is going to develop a drinking problem because of watching an ad? This is what's wrong with America... in many other countries beer ads are everywhere and you don't see children brown-bagging a beer in the playground.
- ineedasername 7y agoWho said anything about a drinking problem? But ads that glorify and make drinking seem exotic/cool/whatever can normalize underage drinking, or any activity for that matter: maybe you're aware of the massive vaping craze among the young, partly as a result of viral social media that does that same thing. Don't act like media exposure can't have any impact on expectations, social norms, and the like. And take notice of the fact that in the 80s and 90s when awareness of this sort of advertising issue curtailed such advertising in traditional media, things like incidents of drunk driving and related accidents/deaths began their years-long decline.
- UnFleshedOne 7y agoThis is another reason why adblockers are a must (while they still work anyway) if you let a child near the screen. There is pretty much no ad that is acceptable to be shown to small children. Anyone younger than 30 y/o or whatever the age where brain development is largely complete.