5 ms·
Taxation is at the heart of what makes the state possible, and it's the state, as a guarantor of justice and peace, which makes creating and keeping wealth poss
by barrkel 16y ago
Taxation is at the heart of what makes the state possible, and it's the state, as a guarantor of justice and peace, which makes creating and keeping wealth possible. The wealthy benefit more from this arrangement, and it's fair that they are taxed more as a result. I presume you're not arguing against the existence of the state, or the need for taxation for its upkeep.
Given the need for taxation, making taxation fair requires information about economic transactions. But there's a balance to be struck here: having the state be informed about the details of every transaction, tied to each individual, would probably be too dangerous for liberty. But on the other hand, lack of oversight will lead to evasion and free-riding. So it seems that it's best to put effort in investigation in proportion to detecting potential free-riders.
Large amounts of money held in opaque arrangements abroad would seem to me to have a high probability of abuse; and with the numbers of people involved being small, the instrumental loss of liberty in having these arrangements investigated seems to me small compared to the free-riding risk.
I also object to the argument you've used; it gives me a slimy feeling reading it. You've tried to drag in this notion of privacy and respect by association with "professionals", attorneys, priests and spouses (!), to what amounts to hired thugs protecting a box of valuables. Banks spend a lot on appearances because they need to give their customers the impression that they're safe places for their customers' money, but at the end of the day, they're out to extract as much of that money as they can. Banking isn't a respectable business, particularly these days. They're a necessary part of the economic infrastructure, a bit like water supply and sewers are to cities.
- pragmatic 16y agoCould a system such as a national sales tax, provide privacy _and_ revenue at the same time? We need to collect data b/c the gov't has to know about your income, your investments, etc, etc. But how about a (hypothetical) system where you only pay taxes when you purchase goods. There wouldn't seem to be any fundamental reason to keep information on _who_ purchased what. Just the fact that the transaction occurred.
- davidw 16y ago"Hypothetically", in Italy, lots of cash transactions with no receipts happen because of the VAT, which is something like a sales tax.
- rbanffy 16y agoBrazil tried to move this into the banking system - all withdrawals were taxed. It was not very popular, but it was effective and devilishly hard to dodge. OTOH, companies routinely exchange services and that kind of transaction is very hard to tax.
- rst 16y agoA lot of European countries have tax structures biased much more heavily towards "value-added taxes" (VATs), which are, in effect, sales taxes on steroids. (Also local governments in the US.) One problem, though, is that in practice, sales taxes are generally regressive --- the poor spend a much larger fraction of their income than the rich, and so wind up getting (relatively) more heavily taxed.
- mkup 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairTax http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairTax
- lionhearted 16y agoI thought this was a balanced and nuanced comment until you bring up "a slimy feeling" and "hired thugs", which is probably not conducive to clear and rational discussion. That said, it's certainly possible to run an orderly taxation system with information that's publicly available - the more you require people to report their affairs to the authorities, the more chance of abuse you have. I'm personally of the belief that the sanest form of taxation is taxing assets held in a jurisdiction - then you're paying directly for what's protected. So tax property, and owned stocks and bonds perhaps. If you need someone to report all the money they have outside of your jurisdiction, everywhere, well I think that gets kind of scary. Anyways, good discussion - armed thugs doesn't make for smart conversation, but good analysis overall.
- barrkel 16y agoI do not want to be dishonest when I comment. A large portion of the motivation for me replying was the emotional distaste I got from reading your argument, and I didn't want to deny it as a bias by pretending to some kind of intellectual distance and objectivity.
- lionhearted 16y agoFair enough, but both sides can play the "armed thugs" card, and then we wind up in a "screw the man!!!! the government is just thugs with guns!" "no dude screw the corporations!!! the banks is just thugs with guns!!!" discussion... which is bad. You can characterize any political position you don't like with emotional language, but it makes it harder to get to truth. You did write some really good points, that's why I thought it was a shame that the emotional language comes in... it's possible to do without it. Most people feel emotionally about their politics, but emotional language rallies your side at the expense of alienating the other side, and then discussion breaks down.
- barrkel 16y agoThis subthread is unfortunately meta; I guess all I want to add is that I felt that your comment relied for much of its force on a rhetorical and psychological trick of associating the banking relationship with the relationship one might have with a doctor or one's spouse. I really do think banks gain a kind of veneer of respectability from their proximity to money, rather than an intrinsic worth in what they do. But scratch the surface, and atavistic greed oozes out.
- pmjordan 16y agoThere's a simple solution to the tax problem: charge a flat tax rate on gains on "secret" assets, levied by the financial institutions to which they have been entrusted. Many countries do this (I'm fairly sure Switzerland is among them) [1]. A problem only arises when the home country gets greedy and wants a piece of that tax pie. I'm sure you could come up with some system by which the destination of the money is estimated and the aggregate taxes paid to that country, but that's probably not seen as enough. [1] Austria uses a system like this - capital gains are flat-taxed at 25% unless you choose to declare them together with other income, falling under income tax (you'd be pretty stupid to do this considering the lowest income tax rate here is 36.5%, but that's another matter). This frequently causes the OECD and the US (the only country to tax its non-resident citizens, as far as I know) exert pressure on Austria (and Switzerland) to try to get them to drop banking confidentiality; they've had some success lately, privacy has been somewhat eroded.
- yardie 16y agoSwitzerland already does this. EU members were pressuring them to release bank information (they aren't part of the EU but are completed surrounded by it). So the new compromise is they don't release the bank records but the pool all the money each country is supposedley owed and forwards it to them. The problem is the other countries don't trust the swiss. They are basically being handed a bag of money and being told trust us. Underreporting taxes benefits the 2 parties with all the information (the swiss and their account holders) and the 3rd is left totally in the dark.
- Erwin 16y agoThat's the ESD (Europen Unions Saving) directive which Switzerland agreed to. So (I think 35%) now of interest related gains is anonymously delivered with a wink to the country where the secret account holder resides. Here in Denmark tax authorities have used that anonymous amount transferred to estimate amount of money in Swiss banks which is supposedly enormous. They've also gone further, like confiscate data about years of foreign credit card payments by Danish shops and search out anyone using a card from a foreign tax haven country based on e.g. shipping addresses for online shopping, or address supplied for hotels and airplane tickets. Except a few high-profile cases like a famous golf player, this had curiously limited criminal consequences, seems like 98% of those caught where just told to pay the tax and interest on the suspicious amounts. The next step in the tax fraud battle is analysis of all bank payments from Danish bank to any bank in tax haven countries. The credit card analysis was done in Sweden previously, so it wouldn't surprise me other countries started using that method as well.
- cynicalkane 16y agoWell, you can say the same stuff about anything, really. You can say that, for example, the law is what makes the state possible, and creating and keeping wealth But this does not excuse a breach of attorney-client privilege. A lawyer who "blew the whistle" on a murderer would face severe penalties. You can't just invoke the importance of the state here--you have to say why the situation is different for banking, but you only address this particular point with childish name-calling and complaints about injured feelings.
- bellaire 16y agoActually, privileges are exceptions to the rule, and they each have their own justifications. The rule as stated is fine, and any privilege must be specifically justified on its own. Attorney-client privilege and psychiatric privilege exist for different reasons. Attorney privilege comes from the necessary functioning of the judicial system, as you pointed out. Psychiatric privilege, in the opinion of the U.S. Supreme Court, "serves the public interest, since the mental health of the Nation's citizenry, no less than its physical health, is a public good of transcendent importance" What is the reason that a banking privilege should exist? What "public good" is being served by protecting private transactions that outweighs the harm done by evasion of tax laws or other regulations? That's a difficult question to answer, and simply saying "it's the same as other privileges" is not sufficient.
- tedunangst 16y agoActually, a lawyer who fails to blow the whistle about a potential murder can face severe penalties. Privilege only extends to information or facts about past actions, it doesn't apply to future or ongoing circumstances, and definitely not if you're complicit in the crime. The banking analogy would be a banker who can't reveal how much money you used to have. Current balance would not be privileged.
- kiba 16y agoWhat if there is no way for government to control the money supply, see who use it, and implement regulation? That mean the ability to tax fall down like a house of cards and we have to look for alternative ways of running society.
- watchandwait 16y agoThe state is hardly the "guarantor of justice and peace." Governments use deadly force and have created the greatest horrors of humanity. In the 20th century alone the state created the Holocaust, deliberately starved tens of millions to death from the Ukraine to China, and obliterated entire cities with nuclear and firebomb weapons. Indeed, around the world today, as many people are oppressed by state power as liberated by it.
- barrkel 16y agoThe state's justification is as guarantor of justice and peace - even broken regimes have laws and courts. Certainly, some states are better at it than others, but I don't think the anarchy of a Somalia is better. I believe the statistics hold out that, in terms of proportion of human population suffering, modern times are better than all historical times, and are continuously improving. If we had a mechanism that improved states, that worked reliably in changing oppressive governments, I'd support it. I don't think we have such a mechanism, though. In short, I support improving states where possible, I deplore bad states, and I think the alternatives to states that we have thus far seen in history are worse than states.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI don't think the anarchy of a Somalia is better. Somalia isn't anarchy. It's several states, some of which are very bad (Islamic theocracies and kleptocracies). That said, it's unclear that Somalia's current set of several competing governments is worse than the single government they had before, or worse than Somalia's neighbors. http://namcub.accela-labs.com/pdf/Better_Off_Stateless.pdf http://namcub.accela-labs.com/pdf/Better_Off_Stateless.pdf
- borism 16y agoSomalia isn't anarchy. even the link you provide begins with: Could anarchy be good for Somalia’s development? yet you still would argue to the contrary - that lawless warlords-dominated failed state isn't anarchy?
- nivertech 16y agoThe government can exist without taxation. Government provide services (security, healthcare, city planning, etc.) The problem is that Government is a monopolist. I have no problem to pay for the services, given I really need them and I have right to choose from which vendor to buy these services. Right now peoples only choice is to emigrate to another country. The other ugly face of tax system is that many, otherwise productive hours and resources, wasted for such a non-productive activity as accounting.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoRight now peoples only choice is to emigrate to another country. Even that choice doesn't work well. The US government considers you an indentured servant. Even if you stop consuming the services they are providing with tax dollars, you are obligated to keep paying for them 10 years.
- redrobot5050 16y agoNo, that's incorrect. Yes, the US is one of the few governments that will tax you for income earned outside of the united states or while living aboard as a US citizen, but if you renounce your citizenship, you're off the hook for taxes. You need to file a tax return and declare income, but you don't pay taxes.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoP.L. 104-191 contains changes in the taxation of U.S. citizens who renounce or otherwise lose U.S. citizenship. In general, any person who lost U.S. citizenship within 10 years immediately preceding the close of the taxable year, whose principle purpose in losing citizenship was to avoid taxation, will be subject to continued taxation. http://travel.state.gov/law/citizenship/citizenship_778.html http://travel.state.gov/law/citizenship/citizenship_778.html
- furyg3 16y agoAs an American living abroad, I've come across this several times. But how on earth do they enforce this? If you live in Europe, (presumably) have EU citizenship, and have renounced your US citizenship, what jurisdiction does the US have over you?
- tlb 16y agoSome states are not pure guarantors of justice and peace. Some are downright kleptocracies. Many deposits in Swiss bank accounts are from people who need to secure their wealth from corrupt local officials. The US is not a kleptocracy, but Olenicoff (the American who Birkenfeld smuggled diamonds for) has ample experience with them. A bio reads: Having escaped Stalin’s forced repatriation campaign [from Iran], the Olenicoffs sewed what little money they had into their coat linings and sailed for America. In that situation, a banker who helped them might be called a hero.
- natnat 16y agoOther deposits in Swiss bank accounts are from the very kleptocrats who keep their citizens from having any money. Where do you think Kim Jong-il keeps his billions? (Actually, he probably keeps it in a number of countries, like Switzerland, Luxembourg, and the Cayman Islands, just in case some of it gets siezed. But the point still stands.)