3 ms·
> It's not a straw man, it's history/law. It's not, at least based on the evidence provided by you thus far. The Supreme Court has not ruled on the availabili
by airstrike 7y ago
> It's not a straw man, it's history/law.
It's not, at least based on the evidence provided by you thus far.
The Supreme Court has not ruled on the availability of sources today, so your argument can't be really considered historical.
At best you may claim that based on past ruling, the SCOTUS is likely to rule that reviving the rule would infringe on the right to free speech. Even then, I'd argue precisely for the opposite, again based on the evidence you presented, i.e. Red Lion Broadcasting Co v. FCC.
I refer you to https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-supreme-court/395/367.html https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-supreme-court/395/367.html (emphasis mine):
> The FCC's statutory mandate to see that broadcasters operate in the public interest and Congress' reaffirmation, in the [395 U.S. 367, 368] 1959 amendment to 315 of the Communications Act, of the FCC's view that the fairness doctrine inhered in the public interest standard, support the conclusion that the doctrine and its component personal attack and political editorializing regulations are a legitimate exercise of congressionally delegated authority. Pp. 379-386.
> 2. The fairness doctrine and its specific manifestations in the personal attack and political editorial rules do not violate the First Amendment. Pp. 386-401.
> (a) The First Amendment is relevant to public broadcasting, but it is the right of the viewing and listening public, and not the right of the broadcasters, which is paramount. Pp. 386-390.
> (b) The First Amendment does not protect private censorship by broadcasters who are licensed by the Government to use a scarce resource which is denied to others. Pp. 390-392.
> (...)
> (e) It has not been shown that the scarcity of broadcast frequencies, which impelled governmental regulation, is entirely a thing of the past, as new uses for the frequency spectrum have kept pace with improved technology and more efficient utilization of that spectrum. Pp. 396-400.
And last but certainly not least:
> Believing that the specific application of the fairness doctrine in Red Lion, and the promulgation of the regulations in RTNDA, are both authorized by Congress and enhance rather than abridge the freedoms of speech and press protected by the First Amendment
I don't see from that how one may conclude that "promoting a variety views that could supersede the broadcaster's right to free speech only when a limited number of sources [is] available", but I'm also not really familiar with case law to argue fervently one way or another.