3 ms·
So, as a user, how can I signal "I don't care; stop showing me this popup on every site?" Because if the answer is "per-site signaling," that's soft encouragem
by shadowgovt 7y ago
So, as a user, how can I signal "I don't care; stop showing me this popup on every site?"
Because if the answer is "per-site signaling," that's soft encouragement to keep using the same sites so I don't need to see that tedious notification and it rewards big players over small players (and defeats some of the benefit of the WWW as a hyperlinked network of data that's fairly location-agnostic).
- raverbashing 7y ago> as a user, how can I signal "I don't care; stop showing me this popup on every site?" That's on the website unfortunately > that's soft encouragement to keep using the same sites so I don't need to see that tedious notification and it rewards big players over small players I agree, I would want the same option (since I use privacy browser extensions I don't care), it's not the users fault the small sites are playing it dumb and using some generic annoying "we value your privacy" popup BS.
- shadowgovt 7y ago... but it may be the fault of the law, since the penalties are significant if small sites don't play the issue conservatively.
- raverbashing 7y agoFault of the law in which way? The GDPR does not require continuous confirmation of consent, only that they're allowed to withdraw consent at any time > The GDPR does not indicate a shelf life for consent. Theoretically, a person’s consent is indefinite, https://gdpr.eu/gdpr-consent-requirements/ https://gdpr.eu/gdpr-consent-requirements/ > since the penalties are significant if small sites This is FUD, proportionality is used when calculating penalties
- shadowgovt 7y ago> This is FUD, proportionality is used when calculating penalties Can you point to where in the law that guarantee is given? Furthermore, given the previous penalty was "none," any penalty can probably be considered significant for website operators who were previously assuming nearly zero risk in running their sites.
- raverbashing 7y agohttps://gdpr.eu/article-83-conditions-for-imposing-administrative-fines/ https://gdpr.eu/article-83-conditions-for-imposing-administr... Paragraph 1. > Each supervisory authority shall ensure... in each individual case be effective, proportionate and dissuasive. Paragraph 2. a) > the nature, gravity and duration of the infringement... as well as the number of data subjects affected and the level of damage suffered by them Also, as we are discussing this, a lot of this will now apply to CCPA and (in some cases) COPPA
- shadowgovt 7y ago> Also, as we are discussing this, a lot of this will now apply to CCPA and (in some cases) COPPA Yes, and COPPA has terrified YouTube content creators. Wiggle language like "proportionate" (especially when paired with "dissuasive") doesn't assuage the fears of website admins, because it isn't a dollars-and-cents (or, in this case, euros) amount. It's at the behest of a judge, which is not a risk space an admin (particularly one running a site as a secondary function, not as core to their business model) wants to take on. So the law, as structured, encourages those popups everywhere forever. Annoying, to say the least. I don't think I'm spreading the FUD; I think the FUD comes from the ambiguity in the penalties described in the law itself.
- raverbashing 7y agoI'll just add that: if they're so worried about the "huge penalties" why are they taking the cheapest way out and using the first non-compliant popup they came across instead of trying to understand the law and come up with an actual solution?