3 ms·
My main concern with NFC is the security, and I must say I'm not reassured by the "Security" section of this article: > NFC is considered to be inherently secu
by simias 16y ago
My main concern with NFC is the security, and I must say I'm not reassured by the "Security" section of this article:
> NFC is considered to be inherently secure since two physical devices must be brought together in such a short range.
I don't see how that makes it "inherently secure". In the first page, it's written that "the spec does allow for maximum distances of up to 20cm, though 4cm or less is common", I don't know how small NFC readers can be, but if I keep my NFC-enabled card in my pocket someone in a crowded bus or subway could certainly be close enough to gather the data.
Next, they go on to say that "encrypted communication is not a requirement of the NFC specification". Wow. I do hope credit cards and such at least are/will be using encryption.
I don't quite get their last concern however:
> Probably the largest possible threat for most users will be theft of an NFC device. If someone steals an NFC-enabled credit card, for instance, there's nothing to stop them from waving it at compatible pay terminals until the card is reported stolen.
This is not really a problem of the NFC technology per se, if my current visa is stolen it can be abused on online websites the same way. Does it mean that NFC forbids the use of a PIN to allow the transaction? If so, I think it's braindead, it's easy to steal cell phones and if it means that you can go to any ATM and empty my account if you can steal mine, I definitely don't want to use that.
- peterwwillis 16y agoIt's 1-factor security, so it will only ever be as secure as 1-factor; if you can steal it you have access. I can take someone's debit card to the bank drive-up window and empty the account, so yeah, I wouldn't worry about if you carry a debit card around.
- metageek 16y agoDebit cards are 2-factor.
- peterwwillis 16y agoi can use a debit card in stores and online without a pin, and take money out of the bank without a pin at the drive-thru. if all i need is a card that's one factor.
- Someone 16y agoNFC is considered to be inherently secure since two physical devices must be brought together in such a short range. As always, range is a function of broadcast power and receiver sensitivity. Because of that, I expect some hacker will be able to read these things from 10 meters away in no time. Actualy, Google gives me over 250.000 hits on "rfid long range reader" and over 50.000 on "NFC long range reader", so I guess one can already buy such readers.