5 ms·
Lithium-Sulphur has high energy per kilogram which makes it good for transportation. Also high energy per dollar to manufacture which makes it good for grid sto
by JoeAltmaier 7y ago
Lithium-Sulphur has high energy per kilogram which makes it good for transportation. Also high energy per dollar to manufacture which makes it good for grid storage (where weight and size don't matter too much, but cost does).
At the nominal rate of 750 amp hours per kilogram for lithium-Sulphur is well above normal lithium-ion batteries. But compared to gasoline, it raises the bar from 1% vs gas, to 2%. Do I have that right?
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoWhat makes electric cars viable isn't that batteries have anywhere near the energy density of gasoline, it's that if you use them, you get to replace half a ton of engine, transmission, alternator, fuel pump, emissions and exhaust with a <100 pound electric motor, and have that cost and weight budget to use for batteries instead. This naturally makes battery improvements a huge win. If you double power density you can cut the weight of the battery by more than half for the same range, since not only do you get the same power from a lighter battery, now the car is lighter and requires less energy to accelerate.
- hanniabu 7y agoThat's a good point, I wonder what the adjusted energy density calculation compared to gas is when considering the amount of weight removed. Something like this: new weight for energy density calculation = (total battery weight) - (ICE component weight) + (electric motor weight)
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoNowhere near. The Tesla battery pack is 1000 lbs. There are entire cars that don't weigh that. Race car engine is 200lbs. And battery packs have cooling systems too. So no savings there. Specific energy (watts-hours per kilogram) is the entire ballgame with batteries and transportation.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoCan you name a modern production car sold in the US that weighs less than 1000 lbs? Lightest available appears to be the Smart Fortwo at ~2000 lbs. The curb weight of a Model 3 is in the same ballpark as a BMW 3 Series or Ford Taurus. Lighter cars exist but mostly because they're significantly smaller or slower or both.
- audunw 7y ago> And battery packs have cooling systems too. So no savings there. That's not quite true. At the very least, EVs require a much smaller radiator, if it has one at all. Some EVs don't have cooling at all (Nissan Leaf), although that increases degradation in hotter climates. I think his point stands.. An ICE engine weight at least 200lb. With transmission it could be up to 600lb. The Model S engine is 70lbs. You "only" need to halve the weight of a Model S battery for the drivetrain+battery to be in the same ballpark as an ICE drivetrain as far as I can tell.
- Gibbon1 7y agoYou can look at actual numbers. Instead of a Model 3. Lets compare a Chevy Bolt with a Prius. Chevy Bolt is about 3500lbs Prius is about 3000lbs. Chevy Bolts battery weighs 440 kg or about 968lbs. Reduce the battery weight by 1/2 and save 484 lbs. So the weight drops to 3016. So point stands if the battery power density improves 2X then the weight penalty disappears.
- ajuc 7y agoElectric cars are about 3 times as energy-efficient as ICE cars. So it's not 1% to 2% but 3% to 6%. And with other savings (much lighter engine, no need for transmission) it's even better. The problem is with degradation - it seems the new batteries only last 200 cycles.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoIts all problems, so far. Weight, heat, size, charge cycles, range. Its only recently that its been even possible to make a practical electric car. Don't fool yourself - there's a transmission element in an electric car too. The power has to get to the wheels, regardless of the power plant.
- elil17 7y agoAn electric car transmission is a usually a simple reduction (two gears). An ICE transmission is usually a six speed shifter, often with hydraulic controls. A world of difference in terms of weight and maintainability.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoThat's just talking gearbox. Then there's casing, shafts, mounts, cooling. The difference in number of gears is the smaller part.
- ajuc 7y agoThis is Tesla mechanically: https://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-fa63245953aaf5f393e851daca58eac6 https://qph.fs.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-fa63245953aaf5f393e851... Please don't pretend it's anywhere close in complexity and weight to the ICE. Of course if you include batteries then it's heavier. But that's why people are excited for any small change in battery energy density.
- elil17 7y agoThat’s really not that much worse than a lithium ion battery (300-500 charge cycles). Also, higher capacity means less frequent charging.
- zackmorris 7y agoGasoline has about 33 kWh/kg (118.8 MJ/kg): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gasoline_gallon_equivalent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gasoline_gallon_equivalent Unfortunately, internal combustion engines have a pathetic fuel economy since they run at low temperatures (around the boiling point of water). All heat engines are limited by the Carnot efficiency, which improves with higher temperature differential. In practice, other cycles like Otto, Diesel, Rankine and Brayton are lower than Carnot and improve with things like higher compression ratio: Carnot efficiency = (T.hot - T.cold)/T.hot where T is in Kelvin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_efficiency#Carnot_efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_efficiency#Carnot_effi... A low compression, naturally aspirated engine running at room temperature with nothing done to improve fuel economy runs at (373.15 - 298)/373.15 = 20% efficiency. I've heard figures as low as 8% for rubber meets the road efficiency in older passenger cars, which I believe, since we drove a ’68 Cadillac that got 5 mpg back in the 90s when gas was under $1 per gallon. The best modern high compression engines typically achieve 25-30% efficiency at best. So I figure there are about 8-10 kWh/kg (28.8-36 MJ/kg) available in gasoline with modern vehicles. Cars built before ‘70s efficiency standards would be more like 2.5-3 kWh/kg (9-10.8 MJ/kg). Unfortunately, it's not just that people don't care how ridiculously inefficient their vehicles are, it's that politicians corrupted by the fossil fuel industry and vehicle manufacturing lobbies never stop conspiring to lower efficiency standards: https://www.vox.com/2019/4/6/18295544/epa-california-fuel-economy-mpg https://www.vox.com/2019/4/6/18295544/epa-california-fuel-ec... But I digress. Electric motors typically run at about 95% efficiency, so we can probably assume 90% efficiency to the road. That’s over 10 times more efficient than classic cars! Looks like Tesla lithium ion batteries are 0.254 kWh/kg (0.914 MJ/kg): http://theconversation.com/teslas-batteries-have-reached-their-limit-heres-how-they-could-go-further-64765 http://theconversation.com/teslas-batteries-have-reached-the... Which is very close to the theoretical ideal for lithium ion of 0.294 kWh/kg (1.058 MJ/kg): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#Tables_of_energy_content https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#Tables_of_energ... I'm having trouble finding energy densities for the new lithium sulfur batteries: https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/6/1/eaay2757 https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/6/1/eaay2757 https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/advances/6/1/eaay2757/F4.large.jpg?width=800&height=600&carousel=1 https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/advances/6/1/eaay275... I'm going to use their low number of 1200 mAh/kg, working between 1.7 and 2.5 V, so averaging 2.1 V (which is very inaccurate without integration), we can call it about 2.520 kWh/kg (9.072 MJ/kg). That would be about 10 times denser than Tesla batteries. Maybe they are estimating half the density in the real world due to packaging or something, in order to arrive at their "5 times longer battery life" headline. So anyway, the real numbers are: Gasoline 33 kWh/kg 118.8 MJ/kg (ideal) Gasoline 8-10 kWh/kg 28.8-36 MJ/kg (actual for modern vehicle) Gasoline 2.5-3 kWh/kg 9-10.8 MJ/kg (actual for pre-70s vehicle Lithium sulfur 2.520 kWh/kg 9.072 MJ/kg (ideal) Lithium sulfur 1.260 kWh/kg 4.536 MJ/kg (actual) Lithium ion 0.294 kWh/kg 1.058 MJ/kg (ideal) Lithium ion 0.254 kWh/kg 0.914 MJ/kg (actual for Tesla) My numbers might be off by a fair amount, but the important thing here is to think in orders of magnitude. Lithium sulfur is halfway to the energy density of classic cars and aircraft, with all the positives, like electric motors having 10 times the power as gas engines by weight, much higher torque, and substantially higher endurance/simplicity.