18 ms·
My biggest issue with the massive dependencies is not licensing or security. Both are important, but there is an even bigger block. My biggest issue is with th
by csdreamer7 7y ago
My biggest issue with the massive dependencies is not licensing or security. Both are important, but there is an even bigger block.
My biggest issue is with things in the node ecosystem is breakage, especially React libraries. I was following a NetNinja tutorial series on Youtube. I had to use a Firebase-Redux library for a combined React/Redux/Firebase series. There was a security vulnerability with something down the stack only a few months after the tutorial was out. So to use the updated version I had to use the beta version of a Firebase library which broke the tutorial code despite the library change being a point release like 1.4.0-beta2. Either 1.3.0 to 1.4.0 or 1.2.0 to 1.4.0 would be consider a breaking release for this particular dev.
We have a large group of dependencies chained upon each other with maintainers that have different support commitments and styles. React might be the de facto JS system, but it relies on a large system of these 3rd party packages to do deeper functionality which can so easily break things. I already had to peg React itself to an older version to use this tutorial when it was months old.
I realized at this point how much of a pain it would be to maintain this code in my portfolio if I did something with it. Let alone a paid product. I stopped learning React at this point (or at least learning React+Redux+Firebase).
Ruby sorta has this issue too, but it feels the Node ecosystem is much more accelerated. The Rails framework dominates the gem ecosystem so much usually gems break functionality by the version of Rails they support. So gems often will not update or warn of breaking changes based on the Rails version or ActiveRecord which follows Rails versioning. This makes gem dependencies much more manageable.
The node ecosystem does not have a large dominating framework like Rails. Even if you considered React that framework, Facebook breaks it whenever they please. 16.4 which sound like a minor version update break things. While Rails 4.2 was supported for 4 years. jQuery might be years before it breaks support.